June 4, 2006
MAYBE THEY SHOULD HOST A WORLD CUP INSTEAD
France forgets its pains in an old-fashioned love affair (Matthew Campbell, The Sunday Times, June 4th, 2006)
Besieged by social and economic woes, the French are finding little cause for cheer in their everyday lives. So they are escaping into the past, revelling in more glorious chapters of history when they were proud, courageous and strong.While pundits bemoan the country’s decline and loss of status, the public seems to have only scorn for politicians, turning instead to historic figures such as Napoleon and the once reviled Marie Antoinette to bolster the sense of national identity.
More than two centuries after the revolution that sent her to the guillotine, Marie Antoinette has become a national obsession, the subject of books, magazine articles and films revealing a personality more sympathetic and complex than the heartless monster suggested by “Let them eat cake”, the comment widely — but probably wrongly — attributed to her by history.
As for Napoleon, France has never tired of paying homage to the self-proclaimed emperor, and the excitement surrounding the latest crop of films and books about the diminutive Corsican bears all the hallmarks of a personality cult.
Much as we feel their pain, we have our doubts that pining away for Europe’s first modern mass-murdering tyrant and most feckless aristocrat will jump-start a national renewal.
It's no surprise- these obsessions reveal the desire for more of the same- greatness defined by subjugation of others and a life of ease in which everything is yours by right- and it's all about you.
Posted by: BC Monkey at June 4, 2006 9:42 AMCould they not harken back to the the humble "Maid of Orleans"?
Posted by: jess at June 4, 2006 2:41 PMCould they not harken back to the the humble "Maid of Orleans"?
Posted by: jess at June 4, 2006 2:44 PMOJ:
There's a great line from a book called The Bad Catholic's Guide to Good Living, by John Zmirak and Denise Matychowiak, in which the authors discuss the slaughter of the Chouans during the French Revolution and peripherally discuss the Napoleonic aftermath:
We don't have space here to address the whole question of whether it was necessary -- in order to correct the fiscal inefficiencies and backward laws of the French monarchy -- to launch a bloody revolution, create the world's first police state, persecute the Church, decapitate thousands of dissidents and immigratns and then wage war on the rest of Europe for twenty years. You decide.
Posted by: Matt Murphy at June 4, 2006 11:56 PMWhoops, that's "immigrants." Preview is my friend.
Posted by: Matt Murphy at June 4, 2006 11:57 PM