September 5, 2005
PRESUMABLY THEY'RE READY WITH THE NEXT JUSTICE TOO:
Bush Had Considered Roberts As US Chief Justice (Mark H. Anderson, 9/05/05, DOW JONES NEWSWIRES)
U.S. President George W. Bush's decision Monday to quickly resubmit the nomination of Judge John Roberts Jr. to be Chief Justice of the United States was a plan the White House had already considered should the cancer-stricken Chief Justice William Rehnquist retire or die.Posted by Orrin Judd at September 5, 2005 4:46 PM"This had been something in the back of the President's mind in case such a scenario came into being, if the Chief Justice had retired," White House spokesman Scott McClellan said. "The president when he met with (Roberts) knew he was a natural-born leader....The president viewed him as someone who had the leadership qualities needed to be able to lead the court." [...]
Roberts was already on track to be confirmed by the Senate, with some experts predicting he would get 75 or more votes despite opposition from numerous liberal interest groups.
Legal analysts also said Bush's decision to resubmit Roberts for the top high court job will likely result in a seamless transition of leadership at the Supreme Court. However, it's possible the Supreme Court will operate with only eight members while O'Connor's replacement is confirmed, should she decide to go ahead and retire.
"The speed with which the president acted this morning suggests that Roberts was at the top of the White House's list all along for the mistakenly anticipated resignation of the Chief Justice this summer," said Tom Goldstein of the Washington law firm Goldstein & Howe. "Recent developments - in which there has been some inevitable opposition but no serious threat to the confirmation has emerged - likely only solidified the president's views of the matter."
Mark Levy, a Washington attorney with Kilpatrick Stockton LLP, said Roberts " would have less trouble and arouse less controversy than others that could be named."
Rehnquist died three days before the scheduled start of the Senate Judiciary Committee's confirmation hearings for Roberts. Those hearings are certainly to be at least temporarily delayed. But the White House and Senate Republican leaders still want Roberts confirmed by the Senate before the Supreme Court convenes Oct. 3 for its next term.
"I still expect Judge Roberts to be confirmed before the Supreme Court starts its new term on Oct. 3," Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., said, adding "the president has made an excellent choice; Mr. Roberts is one of the most well qualified candidates to come before the Senate."
Now we can pick Robert Bork to replace O'Connor. And since the GOP now controls the Senate, he can insult Ted Kennedy all he wants at the confirmation hearings.
Posted by: Matt Murphy at September 5, 2005 5:46 PMI still think Janice Rogers Brown would be an excellent choice for the O'Connor vacancy.
Posted by: Scott Ferguson
at September 5, 2005 5:55 PM
Ann Coulter would be an excellent replacement for O'Connor.
Posted by: sam at September 5, 2005 8:48 PMBush sure is smiled on by fortune isn't he? I mean, obviously he never plans anything out, as I know since Rick Perlstein says so, and he's a fair and impartial journalist. But now the PFAW and other groups have shot their wad on the most clean cut and inoffensive of nominees. If Rehnquist had gone first they might have held their fire a bit and be in a better position to stop whatever next nominee appears. Probably not, since they're as politically inept as Bush haters think he is. As I said, Bush is a lucky, lucky man.
Posted by: b at September 5, 2005 8:56 PMb - you nailed it. Nothing left to say.
Posted by: obc at September 5, 2005 9:26 PMI thought it was interesting tonight that MSNBC was reporting that Pat Lahey said the Roberts conformation hearing wouldn't start until next week. I wonder if Pat has also called Arlen Spector and informed him of the decision...
Posted by: John at September 5, 2005 10:06 PM