September 28, 2004
TALL MEN WON'T BE VOTING FOR HIM EITHER:
It’s About Abortion, Stupid: And other moral issues. Why John Kerry has trouble making the moral argument (Melinda Henneberger, Sept. 24, 2004, Newsweek)
The Democrats are likely to lose the Catholic vote in November—and John Kerry could well lose the election as a result. It’s about abortion, stupid. And “choice,” make no mistake, is killing the Democratic Party.A recent Zogby poll shows that in key battleground states including Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin, New Hampshire and Pennsylvania, Catholic voters are far more likely than the general public to vote for President George W. Bush over Kerry. In Minnesota, for instance, 60 percent of Catholics say they’ll go for Bush, versus 44 percent of all Minnesotans.
Zogby's Fritz Wenzel told the Catholic News Service he sees these numbers as a reflection of Catholic “concern about the legitimacy of the war in Iraq being overridden by ongoing discomfort with Kerry’s stand on abortion.”
It’s telling that the numbers only started to break that way in midsummer, after heavy news coverage of the debate over whether pro-choice Catholics (John Kerry, for instance. Oh, and John Kerry) were fit to receive communion.
Catholics overwhelmingly disagreed with the idea of turning anyone away from the communion rail. But the whole wafer watch, as one priest I know called it, did serve a purpose. The handful of bishops who raised the issue reminded voters that Kerry is “personally opposed” to abortion, whatever that means, but votes in favor of abortion rights. And that, of course, was the whole point.
Had to be the same geniuses who thought that being a vet would insulate the Senator from his anti-American national security record who thought that being a putative Catholic would get him the Catholic vote. Posted by Orrin Judd at September 28, 2004 10:30 PM
Boy, did that article get Catholics wrong. First of all, the Vatican did not say it was okay to vote for a politician if they were pro-abortion. The Vatican did say if the politician was right about a far graver sin than their pro-abortion stance, than a Catholic could vote their conscious based on where the politician stood on the graver sin. The problem for the Dems is that there are very few graver sins than abortion.
So the writer makes the mistake many others have that if you could just show the Catholics that being green is just as moral as being pro-life, they'd vote the way the Dems want. Problem is, religious people tend to be a little more serious about moral issues and can clearly see that a redwood is not a baby.
Posted by: Buttercup at September 29, 2004 6:18 AMBut, getting on the 60% side of 60/40 issues is divisive, and voters hate that. Thus the Kerry doctrine: win votes by disagreeing with the voters.
Posted by: David Cohen at September 29, 2004 7:45 AMTall men won't be voting for him? Oh yes we will...
http://www.tallguysforkerry.com/
Posted by: Jason Thompson at October 7, 2004 4:16 AM