July 20, 2004

WE FEEL YOUR PAIN, NOW PLEASE GO AWAY

Need some healing and closure? Read on (Margaret Wente, Globe and Mail, July 20, 2004)

I know a woman who once raised a chimp alongside her own kids as part of a scientific study. After a couple of years, the study ended and the chimp was banished to a monkey sanctuary. Chimps are not so very different from us, and he was furious. Many years later, the woman finally went to visit him. As soon as he saw her, he jumped on her, twirled her around a few times by her ankles, and nearly bashed her head in.

That was his way of achieving closure.

If people were more like chimps, life would be much simpler. Think how much money we would save on therapy and costly psychopharmaceuticals if, instead of brooding on the traumas inflicted on us by those we trusted, we simply jumped on them and tried to bash their heads in.

But we have evolved better ways of dealing with our feelings of grief and anger, separation and loss. We have healing and closure.

I am not sure when these terms began to leak from the world of therapy into real life. But now they are ubiquitous. No sooner does some catastrophe strike than people begin declaring that the healing has begun. Soon the victims are forgotten, and the spotlight turns to the real victims -- us.

Without a doubt the most confusing, morally offensive and emotionally debilitating concept the wonderful world of psychology has bequeathed us.

Posted by Peter Burnet at July 20, 2004 2:11 PM
Comments

We don't use taglines at brothersjuddblog, but my favorite at another site was "Keep those grief counselers away from me."

Posted by: Harry Eagar at July 21, 2004 3:56 PM

Well, the chimpanzee method of "acheiving closure" (aka "punching their lights out") does have quite a bit of emotional satisfaction.

And it's a lot cleaner way of fighting than fah-shionable backbiting and endless lawsuits.

Posted by: Ken at July 21, 2004 8:35 PM

Healing has gone beyond it's application to personal tragedies to the political sphere. It's most insipid use is in the promise of presidential candidates to "heal the rift" in the country between right and left, or whites and "people of color", or rich and poor, blah, blah.. What utter nonsense, our political system is based on the notion that these rifts exist and that people should be free to express and act on the differences between themselves.

Posted by: Robert Duquette at July 22, 2004 7:01 PM
« NO, HE IS GOD, HE JUST THINKS HE'S VON KARAJAN: | Main | BLUE BATTLEGROUND: »