June 3, 2004

WHEN MICHAEL JACKSON'S PIMP ATTACKS:

Rabbi calls Madonna 'slut' (Miami Herald, Jun. 03, 2004)

Rabbi Shmuley Boteach, the former friend and advisor to Michael Jackson, has attacked the Material Mom, calling her a ''slut'' and a ``vulgarian.'' [...]

``Was the Kabbalah Centre really so desperate that it is prepared to promote itself through a vulgarian whose main contribution to the culture is porn rock?''

Not surprisingly, Madonna's rep reacted strongly.

''I find Rabbi Boteach's comments regarding Madonna frightening,'' said Liz Rosenberg. ``His vile attacks on her character and as an artist are staggering for someone who professes to be a religious person. . . . I suggest this man take a look at his own character and what problems he may have that would make him feel that he should make statements about a truly beautiful human being that he does not know in the slightest.''


Can you really complain when having based your career on being slutty someone calls you a slut? More to the point, if you've slept with Warren Beatty aren't you a slut by definition?

MORE:
Tales at the intersection of war and popular culture (James Lileks, 6/03/04, Jewish World Review)

Disney just released "On the Front Lines," a DVD set of World War II era propaganda cartoons, training films and educational materials. Donald Duck appeared to be best suited to the lighter offering of the wartime years; no one wanted to see Mickey get shot at, Goofy was too dim to trust with an important job, and Daisy was apparently busy at the munitions plant. [...]

It takes a confident culture to take the average gripes of the enlisted man and put them front and center. But that confidence came from unity. Watching the cartoons, you sense how the war affected nearly every facet of public life, from the color of cigarette packs to ads in the magazines to the draft status of cantankerous ducks. Did it construct consensus or reflect a united people? A little of the former, you suspect, and a good deal more of the latter.

Now art is pressed into service of a higher kind: reminding us that war is horrid. Never mind what you're fighting for; fighting is bad, period. It's better to live on your knees, and who better to remind us than Madonna?

About the time the Disney DVD hit the stores, Madonna launched a new tour. Exciting highlights: She's wearing a blue burqa — and when she whips it off she's wearing an Army uniform! Oh, the irony. Meanwhile, the portentously titled "American Life" grinds on; the audience sees a video in which stuff explodes, children cry, and look-alikes of George W. Bush and Saddam Hussein cuddle together. Because, see, they're really the same. They're both, you know, in charge of guns and stuff. Brave stuff! Brilliant and unexpected. Next perhaps she'll tackle religious hypocrisy! No one's done that since Voltaire retired.


Posted by Orrin Judd at June 3, 2004 9:07 AM
Comments

The rabbi should just give Madonna some time -- if Kabbalah doesn't increase sales of her next CD or revive her flagging movie career, she'll dump it and find some other religion/new age ritual/PETA-approved non-animal sacrificing pagan cult to latch onto within the next two years or so...

Posted by: John at June 3, 2004 9:15 AM

She's not a slut. She has just exercised an uncommonly large number of free choices.

Posted by: Peter B at June 3, 2004 9:15 AM

I like it when pop stars and hollywood actors endorse political campaigns.

It reminds me to take the polar opposite view.

Posted by: Brit at June 3, 2004 9:42 AM

Isn't this the same criticism of the classical music babes that pose in the buff? Or am I missing something?

Posted by: Buttercup at June 3, 2004 10:53 AM

It seems Madonna is trying to re-make her image so that her kids won't insult her when they reach puberty. Good luck.

Posted by: jim hamlen at June 3, 2004 11:05 AM

Buttercup:

Pose with a cello, it's art. Pose with a whip, you're a slut.

Posted by: oj at June 3, 2004 11:09 AM

Poor Madonna, buffeted from all sides from the righteous(ly indignant).

First she's threatened by Islamic terrorists. Then she gets slammed by the good rabbi.

It's a bit hard for me to understand why anyone takes her all that seriously. Still, it's quite possible those Islamic fundamentalists were merely responding naturally after finally getting around to hearing her version of "American Pie" for the first time; while the latter probably took "Papa Don't Preach" a little too much to heart.

One would think they'd have better things to do....

Posted by: Barry Meislin at June 3, 2004 11:31 AM

Considering the company Boteach has tended to keep over the past years (buddying up with Michael Jackson, for one), I don't think he's the guy to be calling anyone a slut, even if the woman happens to be one.

Posted by: Derek Copold at June 3, 2004 12:23 PM

Derek,
Yeah, but even stopped clocks...

Posted by: Roy Jacobsen at June 3, 2004 12:47 PM

Besides, Boteach vs Madonna is pretty damn funny. Nutcase rabbi vs fake Kabbalist--winner=everyone!

Posted by: Brian (MN) at June 3, 2004 1:07 PM

No, his judgment isn't always spot on (actually, sometimes he's way off), but Boteach is bright and articulate, so that he's usually worth listening to and his books are generally compelling.

I imagine he's taken a swing at Madonna because she's one very visible example of the celebritization, the cheapening of Jewish mysticism.

I don't hold her responsible, necessarily; I think it's the snake oil salesmen who are selling it all. It's big, big bucks.

But there's freedom to choose, I guess, and one could do worse.

Posted by: Barry Meislin at June 3, 2004 1:35 PM
« LOOKS LIKE IT'LL PLAY IN PERSIA: | Main | TOUCH THEIR HEARTS WITH FIRE: »