November 22, 2003
THE 13TH STEP:
Recovery. It Can Be So Addicting (Mark Gauvreau Judge, November 23, 2003, Washington Post)
Now that he's out of rehab and back on the job, there's no shortage of people offering Rush Limbaugh advice on his new life as a recovering drug addict. But I think I can offer the pugnacious radio talk show host some advice he's probably not getting: Listen, Rush. Whatever people tell you, recovery is not endless -- and it should not remain the center of your life.In 12-step circles, this is heresy. Once you get bounced into what alcoholics call "the rooms" of Alcoholics Anonymous and other groups -- those church basements where the recovering meet -- it's hammered into you that recovery must be the center of your life, every day, for the rest of your life. This is a self-defeating proposition. Admitting powerlessness and asking for help are signs of honesty and maturity. But making a fetish out of a long-ago disorder and engaging in groupthink are not.
As someone once addicted to alcohol, I've logged many hours in the rooms. I've heard lots of self-aggrandizing stories of debauchery, which are common in the recovery culture. In most of these stories, individuals battle addiction to arrive at the truth that the world doesn't revolve around them -- yet often they still manage to make themselves the center of the universe. They spend years of their lives in a stupor of addiction; then, once sober, they spend years of their lives talking about it.
AA and similar programs do remarkable, life-saving work, but Mr. Judge has it precisely right when he says that they've a tendency to leave the addict totally focused on self. The last step really needs to be the recognition that the Universe has a Center, and you aren't it.
Posted by Orrin Judd at November 22, 2003 4:27 PM
Amen, Orrin. One can't begrudge whatever it takes for those ruined by alcohol, but the psychological, navel-gazing grip these programmes can have can be depressing. They dwell on every tough time they had as kids. I've seen people completely abandon their families because they (the family--kids included) won't "admit" they are addicted too.
The same is true about a lot of womens' counselling and, yes, religious and quasi-religious programmes. AA should have an exit component.
Posted by: Peter B at November 22, 2003 5:17 PMLike a lot of cults, the recovery-industrial complex owns you and will never let you go.
In some sense, all they are doing is replacing various addictions with the one addition that they admit has no cure-- "recovery".
Posted by: Raoul Ortega at November 23, 2003 2:48 PMAmen to Mr. Judge. Something so sensible appeared in the Wapo? I'm genuinely impressed.
Posted by: Joseph at November 23, 2003 4:46 PMRecovery is not something to graduate from, but I'll admit, you have to start taking responsibility for thinking for yourself at some point in the process. AA, like everything, is a tool, and it can be used to heal as well as to escape. When the student is ready, the teacher appears. Power! Peace.
Posted by: Daniel Jaffe, Arizona DUI Defense Lawyer, Scottsdale, AZ at December 5, 2003 12:47 PM