June 6, 2008

GET YOUR RED HOT TULIPS!:

Why oil prices will tank: Arguments that $4-a-gallon gas (or even higher) is here to stay are dead wrong. Housing's boom-and-bust cycle tells you why. (Shawn Tully, 6/06/08, CNN Money)

[E]ven if Saudi Arabia produces at $4 a barrel, if the final, multi-millionth barrel required to heat houses and run cars costs $50, and is produced, for argument's sake, at a flagging field in West Texas, the world price is $50. That's what economists call the equilibrium price: It's where the price that customers are willing to pay meets the production cost, including a cushion, naturally, for profit or "the cost of capital." [...]

So what does that barrel cost today? According to Stephen Brown, an economist at the Dallas Federal Reserve, that final barrel costs just $50 to produce. And when the price is $125, the incentive to pour out more oil, like homebuilders' incentive to build more two years ago, is irresistible.

It takes a while to develop new supplies of oil, but the signs of a surge are already in place. Shale oil costing around $70 a barrel is now being produced in the Dakotas. Tar sands are attracting investment in Canada, also at around $70. New technology could soon minimize the pollution caused by producing oil from our super-plentiful supplies of coal.

"History suggests that when there's this much money to be made, new supplies do get developed," says Brown.

That's just the supply side of the equation. Demand should start to decline as well, albeit gradually.

"Historically, the oil market has under-anticipated the amount of conservation brought on by high prices," says Brown. Sales of big cars are collapsing; Americans are cutting down on driving. The airlines are scaling back flights.

We've learned another important lesson from the housing market: The longer prices stay stratospheric, the worse the eventual crash - simply because the higher the prices and bigger the profit margins, the bigger the incentive to over-produce.

It's even possible that, a few years hence, we could see a sustained period of plentiful oil supplies and low prices, meaning $50 or below.

A similar scenario occurred following the price explosion in the 1970s and early 1980s. The price spike caused the world to cut back sharply on oil consumption. By the mid-80s, oil prices had fallen from almost $40 to around $15. They remained extremely low for two decades.

Posted by Orrin Judd at June 6, 2008 2:25 PM
Comments

McCain is probably hoping the bubble pops in the next five months....

Posted by: PapayaSF at June 6, 2008 10:01 PM

Not a chance. The whole debacle is being orchestrated to last until the election at which time things will return to "normal" even if McCain wins. Even Soros et al. can't keep this up indefinitely.

Posted by: erp at June 7, 2008 9:32 AM

The $10 jump in 1 day yesterday should have clued everybody in that supply and demand aren't driving the price, financial markets are. The GOP needs to hammer on the "Dems won't let us drill locally for oil" meme in order to try and offset the "it's Bush and the GOP's fault" the Dems will use

Posted by: AWW at June 7, 2008 11:48 AM

Don't know how true it is, but I heard many oil tankers are just waiting for the left to return to power to sail in and make everything better.

Posted by: erp at June 7, 2008 2:03 PM

While there are undoubtedly speculative moves going on, let's not forget that there are several 'valid' reasons for the surging price of oil.

Production in the North Sea is down (a bit, as I remember). Production in Nigeria is off about 20%, due to sabotage, violence, theft, and vandalism. Production in Venezuela is down (and we are getting much less than 20 years ago). Production in Russia is down. Production in Mexico is down.

The Saudis can't make up all that difference - in fact, today's WSJ claimed they are just about 2 million bbl per day below full flow (out of a total of about 86 million bbl a day). Pretty close to their limit already.

In the past, a slowdown in US consumption would have already caused a price slide. Not so today, with other markets eager to buy. Perhaps the fungibility of oil is changing.

If Iran and Iraq were pumping near their limits (and selling unfettered to the West, or even China), things would be much looser. The market is tight now, which makes the speculative activity all the more consequential. But I am skeptical that the 'bubble' will pop. The only strategy anyone has right now is to get more from the Saudis. We need to look elsewhere.

Posted by: jim hamlen at June 7, 2008 10:36 PM
« THE PROMISED NIXONLAND: | Main | APPEALING TO THE DEFEATED TRIBES: »