March 20, 2008
SCAB PICKING:
Obama blew it: What the candidate should have said about race (Michael Meyers, March 20, 2008, LA Times)
[I]'d say that considering the nation's undivided attention to this all-important speech, which gave him an unrivaled opportunity to lift us out of racial and racist thinking, Obama blew it.Posted by Orrin Judd at March 20, 2008 12:45 PMI waited in vain for our hybrid presidential candidate to speak the simple truth that there is no such thing as "race," that we all belong to the same race -- the human race. I waited for him to mesmerize us with a singular and focused appeal to hold all candidates to the same standards no matter their race or their sex or their age. But instead Obama gave us a full measure of racial rhetoric about how some of us with an "untrained ear" -- meaning whites and Asians and Latinos -- don't understand and can't relate to the so-called black experience.
Well, I am black, and I can't relate to a "black experience" that shields and explains old-style black ministers who rant and rave about supposed racial differences and about how America ought to be damned. [...]
I expected Obama, who up to now had been steering a perfect course away from the racial boxes of the past, to challenge racial labels and so-called black experiences. We're all mixed up, and if we haven't yet been by the process of miscegenation, trans-racial adoptions and interracial marriage, we sure ought to get used to how things will be in short order.
That would have been the forward-looking message of a visionary candidate. But Obama erred by looking backward -- as far back as slavery. What does slavery have to do with the price of milk at the grocery store?
There is an American race that has been evolving for more than two centuries.
Posted by: ic at March 20, 2008 1:58 PMIf a political speech doesn't end racism by destroying race as a concept, it's a failure?
I guess when you're billed as the Messiah, people raise the bar a bit.
Posted by: Ibid at March 20, 2008 2:10 PMVery nice analogy, Orrin.
Posted by: Jorge Curioso at March 20, 2008 2:22 PM