August 24, 2007
SINCE THE BUREAUCRACIES WOULDN'T COME TO AL QAEDA...:
How Washington Missed 9/11 (Robert Baer, 8/24/07, TIME)
In January 2000 a CIA field station in East Asia found out that two known Qaeda terrorists, Khalid al-Midhar and Nawaf al-Hazmi, were on their way to the United States — and they weren't coming on vacation. But it wouldn't be until August 2001 that CIA headquarters finally would tell the FBI, too late for the agency to track the two down.Posted by Orrin Judd at August 24, 2007 4:03 PMDuring the eighteen months between January 2000 and August 2001 50-60 people at the CIA were aware of al-Hazmi and al-Midhar traveling to the U.S. But no one did anything because the assumption was that someone else had told the FBI. And presumably the FBI was covering the two.
One problem was that communications between FBI and CIA headquarters is ad hoc — usually by telephone, sometimes by a classified telex. An FBI agent assigned to the CIA wrote a telex to the FBI about al-Hazmi and al-Midhar but for reasons that are still unclear it was never sent. There was no mechanism to register the lapse, or that the FBI in fact did not have al-Midhar and al-Hazmi under coverage. The ball was dropped.
The problems were easily correctible. For instance, had the CIA field station in East Asia been able to send a telex directly to FBI headquarters in Washington or FBI field offices in California, where al-Hazmi and al-Midhar ended up, the FBI no doubt would have launched a full field investigation and almost certainly found out about the other 17 hijackers. The chances are the FBI would have stopped 9/11.
The CIA IG's report says there was no "silver bullet" that would have prevented 9/11. I disagree; this was it.
Al-Hazmi and al-Midhar falling between the cracks is not the stuff of conspiracies or simple incompetence. The CIA and the FBI are Cold War institutions that have never shared databases. Their communications systems were never designed to interface. FBI and CIA cultures have never meshed. The FBI collects evidence for trial, the CIA collects information to analyze it. No wonder leads are dropped.
And that is not the only Achilles heel in the system. The CIA IG's report cites the National Security Agency's unwillingness to share raw intercepts with the CIA. Who knows what is in the NSA's raw data bases on al-Midhar and al-Hazmi?
No mention of the Gorelick wall.
Posted by: Gideon at August 24, 2007 4:42 PMRodger. What happened to the post-Watergate, pre-Patriot Act firewall between foreign and domestic intelligence?
Recall what Watergate had been about. Nixon's boys were hoping to catch the Democrats accepting campaign money from their buddies in the KGB.
Part of the post-Watergate Dolchstoss, as if the betrayal of Vietnam and Nicaragua were not enough was the bar between the CIA and the FBI, and the resulting culture of non-cooperation.
Posted by: Lou Gots at August 24, 2007 5:05 PMBob Baer has ever so slightly gone off the deep end. He used to be a staunch opponent of the Iranians and AQ. but then he did his stint for
the movie Syriana. By this time last year; his
revisionist novel; "Blow the House Down" was positing an Iranian source behind the 9/11 plots; they not Osama gave the order to KSM who then
transmitted it to the Hamburg cell. Then this
spring, he appeared in the now infamous Sy Hersh
piece on Lebanon and Saudi Arabia; saying that
Hezbollah is in a position to protect the Maronites.
And Jamie Gorelick wants to be AG in the next Democratic administration....
Posted by: ratbert at August 24, 2007 6:34 PM