December 7, 2006
RATHER FEEBLE BEST SHOT:
One Last Mission for Ship Sunk in Pearl Harbor Attack (Michael E. Ruane, 12/07/06, Washington Post)
On Dec. 6, 1941, the Arizona took on 1.2 million gallons of heavy fuel oil at its berth in Pearl Harbor. The ship was scheduled to make a Christmas trip back to the West Coast the next weekend. The fuel, which was so heavy it had to be atomized for use in the engines, weighed 4,000 tons and was stored in more than 200 tanks, or bunkers, spread across four deck levels throughout the vessel.In the Japanese attack the next morning, a 1,700-pound bomb plunged through the ship's deck, detonating in an ammunition compartment. The explosion obliterated a section of the Arizona's bow, blasted backward toward the stern and vented out the smokestack. It also ignited much of the oil, which burned for three days.
The battleship -- three times the size of the Statue of Liberty -- settled to the bottom in 34 feet of water, along with the bodies of more than 1,100 sailors and Marines.
The Arizona, which was launched in 1915, is 91 and has been submerged for six decades.
It's revealing that the Arizona became the symbol of Pearl Harbor, because it was the exception rather than the rule and obscures just how minimal a threat the Japanese represented, Pearl Harbor Raid, 7 December 1941 -- Post-attack Ship Salvage (Naval Historical Center, 19 November 2000)
During the weeks following the Japanese raid, a great deal of repair work was done by the Pearl Harbor Navy Yard, assisted by tenders and ships' crewmen. These efforts, lasting into February 1942, put the battleships Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Tennessee; cruisers Honolulu, Helena, and Raleigh; destroyers Helm and Shaw, seaplane tender Curtiss, repair ship Vestal and the floating drydock YFD-2 back into service, or at least got them ready to steam to the mainland for final repairs. The most seriously damaged of these ships, Raleigh and Shaw, were returned to active duty by mid-1942.Five more battleships, two destroyers, a target ship and a minelayer were sunk, or so severely damaged as to represent nearly total losses. These required much more extensive work just to get them to a point where repairs could begin. Starting in December 1941 and continuing into February 1942, the Navy Yard stripped the destroyers Cassin and Downes of servicible weapons, machinery and equipment. This materiel was sent to California, where it was installed in new hulls. These two ships came back into the fleet in late 1943 and early 1944.
To work on the remaining seven ships, all of them sunk, a salvage organization was formally established a week after the raid to begin what would clearly be a huge job. Commanded from early January 1942 by Captain Homer N. Wallin, previously a member of the Battle Force Staff, this Salvage Division labored hard and productively for over two years to refloat five ships and remove weapons and equipment from the other two. Among its accomplishments were the refloating of the battleships Nevada in February 1942, California in March, and West Virginia in June, plus the minelayer Oglala during April-July 1942. After extensive shipyard repairs, these four ships were placed back in the active fleet in time to help defeat Japan. The Salvage Division also righted and refloated the capsized battleship Oklahoma, partially righted the capsized target ship Utah and recovered materiel from the wreck of the battleship Arizona. However, these three ships were not returned to service, and the hulls of the last two remain in Pearl Harbor to this day.
MORE:
A Day of Infamy, Two Years of Hard Work (ROBERT TRUMBULL, 12/07/06, NY Times)
Here, 64 years late, are edited excerpts from a dispatch sent to The New York Times by Robert Trumbull, the paper’s correspondent at Pearl Harbor. It details a triumphant but mostly forgotten story of World War II: the salvage effort that rebuilt the Pacific Fleet after the Japanese attack.Posted by Orrin Judd at December 7, 2006 8:30 AMA city of seamen, engineers, divers, carpenters, welders, pipe fitters and other industrial workers arose overnight at the Pearl Harbor Navy Yard. Its slogan was “We keep them fit to fight,†and within two years the yard raised all the damaged ships except the Arizona and the Utah.
One year after the attack, with the harbor still choked with wreckage, Trumbull wrote a 15,000-word, three-part series about the round-the-clock operation. But wartime censorship killed the articles. Like the civilian rescue workers and hardhats at ground zero, the shipyard workers dispersed, unheralded, when the job was done. Trumbull died in 1992.
Of course, had Nagumo launched a second attack against the tenders, the docks, the repair yards and shops, and other support equipment, Pearl would have been out of commission for a long time. And if the Japanese had been really gutsy, they would have attacked a few days later, and sunk the Enterprise in the harbor.
A good lesson for all on warfare. I doubt if anyone on the ISG has even an inkling, though.
Posted by: ratbert at December 7, 2006 9:46 AMNo, it wouldn't have mattered. The lesson is all our wars are volitional.
Posted by: oj at December 7, 2006 10:49 AMEven the Japanese didn't expect to defeat us. They figured if they made it too hard for defeat them, we'd quit. In hindsight, they shouldn't have attacked Pearl Harbor at all. We might have ignored their war with Britain if they hadn't.
Posted by: Brandon at December 7, 2006 11:56 AMIn hindsight, they should have gone with their "Southern Strategy"* and not messed with mainland China. No China adventure, no oil and steel embargo, no Pearl Harbor.
*Or whatever it was called. The strategy was that they were going to take Indonesia and other oil-rich parts of SE Asia and leave China alone until it was more convenient. I'm at work and my Google-fu is weak today.
Posted by: Bryan at December 7, 2006 12:45 PMHad out carriers been at Pearl and/or the IJN had destroyed to fuel depots on Oahu, there would have been no battle of Midway as America would not have had a functioning fleet to counter Japanese advances for another year.
We would have won, eventually. Sometime in 46 or 47.
Posted by: Baha at December 7, 2006 6:12 PMA whole year? Wow....
But how would it have slowed the Manhattan Project?
Posted by: oj at December 7, 2006 7:04 PMThere's a mind-boggling passage from Paul Johnson's book Modern Times listing the incredible disparities between American and Japanese supplies of raw materials. We're talking three-to-one, five-to-one, even ten-to-one ratios here. You'll note we were the ones shutting off the spigot and not vice-versa.
The part that makes my brain go tilt is that the Japanese essentially recognized all this and went ahead anyway, even likening their decision to jumping blindfolded off a temple. Yeah, it was something like that.
It's one thing to have read stats like that in various books and quite another to have them all usefully compiled in front of you. I remember a history professor once mentioning a Japanese military man who was well-aquainted with America and gave a wise assessment: If the Japanese attacked America, they would have to invade the west coast and reach Washington, D.C. before the Americans made any kind of peace with them.
The old Churchillian question is awfully useful here: Just what kind of people did they think we were?
Posted by: Matt Murphy at December 7, 2006 8:08 PMOur main advantage throughout the Long War has been that the enemy is literally deranged.
Posted by: oj at December 7, 2006 8:11 PMYamamoto knew who we were - he lived here and studied at Harvard. I don't remember if Matt's reference is from him or not (like his famous statement about waking the sleeping giant). But Tojo and the other gangsters were from the Army. They didn't know squat about America. They learned.
The war would have been delayed (with a second attack at Pearl), but we still could (and would) have dropped the bombs, even if we had to fly in from somewhere else. But the real difference might have been an attempted Japanese invasion of Australia (presuming no battle in the Coral Sea). That would have been a real mess for the Japanese, however.
Posted by: ratbert at December 8, 2006 9:50 AM