June 25, 2006

SURE WE ALL OWN OUR OWN HOMES AND HAVE BURGEONING 401kS, BUT WE'RE BROKE, NO?:

West Windsor's Dilemma of Values (Kristen Fountain, 6/25/06, Valley News)

The Hales have lived and farmed in the shadow of Mount Ascutney since the Revolutionary War.

Brothers from Scotland settled in the western part of the town, said Maria Hale, 67, who lives along one of the long fields off the Brownsville-Hartland Road that the family has owned for generations. Summer days find her brother, Joel Hale, 71, outside his home down the street doing what he has done since he was a child: tending the herd.

Unbeknownst to them, however, the ground beneath their feet has been turning to black gold.

In recent years, out-of-towners from Massachusetts, New Jersey, Maryland and Florida and elsewhere have purchased tracts in the surrounding hills for $10,000 to $20,000 an acre, using them for homes and weekend havens. Their willingness to pay such hefty sums has sent the values of large parcels sky high.

West Windsor residents recently learned that a townwide revaluation completed in May has made the combined taxable value of their properties 2½ times greater than before. But that increase pales compared with the shock being felt by residents such as the Hales, whose farm- and forestland is appreciating at a much faster pace because of its potential value as a country estate.

“Strange world,” Joel Hale said recently, shaking his head as he stared out at the sun-dappled pasture from the vantage point of his tractor seat. To him and his cows, he said, “it ain't worth any more than it was.”

But according to the revaluation, his 236 acres, previously assessed for tax purposes at $330,000, is now valued at almost $2.8 million. Their previous tax bill was around $8,000, said Joel Hale. This year, it could be $40,000 or higher. [...]

Josephine Bernatchez, 52, and her brother David own the land their father bought for a dairy farm in 1922. Their 205 acres on Bryant Road increased in value in the reassessment from $283,400 to $2,373,800, making her worry. “We're not among the people with a lot of money,” she said. “Are we going to lose our homes?”


Lesson One: Never let a cow make an important financial decision.

Posted by Orrin Judd at June 25, 2006 10:55 AM
Comments

The cows should consider whether they might prefer a retirement pasture in Florida. Staying in Vermont may require extra milkings.

Posted by: pj at June 25, 2006 11:02 AM

Next step is for the "Growth Management Advocates" to make it impossible to sell this land as a subdivision or shopping mall, while keeping the assessment high so the farmers go broke and the city/county finds itself some new "greenspaces" and city parks, or something to resell to a mall developer without having to pay for it. Eminent domain is for the chumps who are in a hurry.

Posted by: Raoul Ortega at June 25, 2006 12:14 PM

The old timers should stop their unseemly grousing. Sheesh! Vermont is a socialist paradise and some eggs need to be broken to make an omelet. No thats not how the saying goes . . . anyway some win, some lose, but it really doesnt matter which is who.

Itll all work out for the best in the end. Taking care of all those cows was getting tedious anyway and theyll soon get to love living in the little condo where they can brush up on their checker playing skills.

Posted by: erp at June 25, 2006 12:50 PM

I see death tax ramifications here, does anyone else????

Here's a farmer that 1 newsie/expert claimed they couldn't find.

Posted by: Sandy P at June 25, 2006 2:36 PM

SP: it doesn't matter whether there's death tax or not, the local govt. is going to take away the farmers' lands, under Kelo, well before they die. Local politicos' friends and families want to be rewarded now not in 10 or 15 years for someone's death.

Posted by: ic at June 25, 2006 2:56 PM

Kelo is a godsend for these folks--they don't even have to sell the land themselves.

Posted by: oj at June 25, 2006 3:02 PM

increased in value in the reassessment from $283,400 to $2,373,800

Why can't I have problems like that?

Posted by: Brandon at June 25, 2006 3:04 PM

This has been going on in Vermont for years. Next town meeting all the flatlanders will be clamoring for more paved roads, a professional fire department, city water and 911 service. The Hales will get a hansome tax bill to match their new assesment.

Their kids will live in a trailer in Judevine.

Posted by: Jason Johnson at June 25, 2006 7:38 PM
« SKIMMING THE CREAM: | Main | FORTUNATELY, THIS PRESIDENT ISN'T A RACIST: »