May 13, 2006

THE SOLUTION, OF COURSE, IS BOATLOADS OF FREE CONDOMS


A rapist's paradise
(Leonard Stern, The Ottawa Citizen, May 13th, 2006)

Women's groups in South Africa were outraged at the acquittal Monday of Jacob Zuma, the country's former deputy president, who had been charged with rape, sparked outrage. Sexual violence is out of control in that nation. Tens of thousands of rapes are reported to police every year, though experts believe that at least as many additional ones go unreported. A bizarre pathology is plaguing South African men, and the trial of Mr. Zuma suggested that not even the nation's leaders are immune.

Researchers in fields from political science to psychology are trying to figure out why so many South African men rape. Observers note that South Africa is both a rigidly patriarchal society and in many ways a lawless one, two factors that, when combined, put women in a vulnerable spot.

Yet there are other patriarchal, lawless places in the world, and women there are not being systematically raped. One intriguing theory holds that the rape epidemic is a legacy of the apartheid years. Under the humiliating apartheid system, black South African men were rendered officially powerless -- politically neutered. The culture of rape represents a dysfunctional effort by black men to assert themselves and project power.

A similar phenomenon could be said to exist in U.S. inner cities, where black men who are marginalized in the larger society embrace a hip-hop culture whose defining feature is a grotesque misogyny.

In Mr. Zuma's case, his accuser was a 31-year-old HIV-infected woman -- an AIDS activist, actually -- who was staying at his house. In the end, the court sided with Mr. Zuma, 64, who argued that the sex was consensual.

It emerged in the course of the trial that the sex was unprotected. This also is interesting. Not only was Mr. Zuma a former deputy president of the country, but he once headed the South African AIDS Commission. Massive AIDS-awareness programs are under way across Africa, but you really have to wonder how effective these are if the one man in all of South Africa who should know better is having unprotected sex with an openly HIV-positive woman. For the record, Mr. Zuma himself is HIV-negative.

Never mind that this should have bolstered the accuser's contention that the incident was rape. Many HIV carriers engage in unsafe sex, but a woman who is personally and publicly involved in AIDS prevention presumably would behave responsibly in a consensual affair. It strains belief that a 31-year-old AIDS activist agreed to a one-night stand with a man nearly old enough to be her grandfather and also agreed to do so without protection.

It sure is depressing to see Mr. Stern’s admirable outrage dissipate so quickly in drivel about past exploitations and “marginalized” men. Maybe he should start asking African women what they think.

Posted by Peter Burnet at May 13, 2006 10:14 AM
Comments

I didn't check who posted this before reading, so I assumed that we were heading towards a point about how the so-called Realists are incapable of seeing facts that contradict political correctness; in this case the low risk of female to male transmission of AIDS.

Posted by: David Cohen at May 13, 2006 10:56 AM

Mr. Cohen, I think this was a standard 'Men are Pigs' post.

Posted by: Robert Mitchell Jr. at May 13, 2006 11:13 AM

Yeah, sorry about that, Robert. From now on in posts about rape plagues I'll try and be more even-handed.

Posted by: Peter B at May 13, 2006 11:29 AM

I didn't mean to give you any grief, Mr. Burnet, but while we have you, was there a deeper point that Mr. Cohen and I missed?

Posted by: Robert Mitchell Jr. at May 13, 2006 11:49 AM

Yeah, right - rape is a result of apartheid. SHEEEESH! Maybe if they were raping white women (Not Even Then Would I Buy That!), but the rape of black women by black men is a result of apartheid? ? ?

Posted by: obc at May 13, 2006 12:04 PM

"It strains belief that a 31-year-old AIDS activist agreed to a one-night stand with a man nearly old enough to be her grandfather and also agreed to do so without protection."

Could it be she didn't like him?

I've been told by an acquaintance, a white male hetero Democrat, who spends time and money in S.A. each year assisting the Police Forces and Armed Forces fight AIDS within their ranks; about 75% of them are HIV positive.

Posted by: Genecis at May 13, 2006 5:22 PM

Researchers in fields from political science to psychology are trying to figure out why so many South African men rape.

Shouldn't they be trying to figure out why, in other societies, so many men don't rape? That is the true puzzler. The reason that South African men rape is simple - because they are getting away with it.

Posted by: Robert Duquette at May 14, 2006 11:01 AM
« BACKHANDED FAVOR (via Tom Morin): | Main | SURE, IT’S ALL ABOUT THE SCIENCE »