May 18, 2006
JUST PRETEND THEY MATTER, FOR APPEARANCE SAKE:
Wider Briefing for Lawmakers on Spy Efforts (MARK MAZZETTI and SHERYL GAY STOLBERG, 5/18/06, NY Times)
Classified briefings provided to lawmakers on Wednesday about a controversial domestic eavesdropping program have smoothed what might have been a contentious path toward confirmation for Gen. Michael V. Hayden as director of the Central Intelligence Agency, senators and Congressional officials said. [...]Lawmakers have said that even without Wednesday's briefing, by Lt. Gen. Keith B. Alexander, the current N.S.A. director, the Senate was likely to confirm General Hayden. Yet Wednesday's briefings diminished the prospect that the hearings, before the Senate Intelligence Committee, would become a focus of hostile questions from Democrats and Republicans on the panel who had not been briefed on the program, in which the security agency monitored, without court warrants, the international telephone and e-mail communications of those suspected of having links to terrorists. [...]
One senior Democratic Senate aide, who was granted anonymity because he is not authorized to speak publicly about his party's strategy, said of Thursday's hearings, "Democrats were much more likely to cause problems if they weren't able to ask knowledgeable questions during the hearing."
Constitutional law isn't secret but none of the Senators asked knowledgeable questions of John Roberts or Sam Alito. Posted by Orrin Judd at May 18, 2006 10:22 AM
They may not ask smart questions, but they'll still leak the content of the closed door briefing with Hayden within the next few days, in exchange for stories making it seem like they asked smart questions when the camera's weren't rolling.
Posted by: John at May 18, 2006 11:35 AMHey, let's give the Senators a break--it has been made clear that you must have an Ivy League education to comprehend constitutional law. Having gone to, say, SMU, or wherever many Senators probably went, means you're just not qualified to understand it.
Posted by: b at May 18, 2006 5:19 PMJudging from the results in the Solomon Amdt. case (Rumsfeld v. Nearly Every Smarty-Pants Law Professor in the World), George Mason is the only law school capable of deciphering the Constitution.
Posted by: Noel at May 19, 2006 1:40 AM