March 6, 2006
ORWELLIAN
Way beyond their age (Justine Ferrari, The Australian, March 7th, 2006)
Half the parents you've met think their little darlings are gifted. It's often a joking remark made between parents: "Of course, my child is terribly advanced, very gifted."Of course, no one seriously considers the child actually might be advanced, which is why gifted-education expert Miraca Gross recoils at the anecdote. "It's a disturbing cliche," she says. "It's one of the reasons why it's so difficult for these children to be recognised.
"A parent trying to explain to a teacher why their child is bored and says they think he is very bright and you can hear the teacher thinking 'here we go again, every parent thinks that'. That's just not true. Most parents are realistic about their child's potential."
When Nadia Bloom was called to her daughter's school in Sydney to be told she should skip two grades, Bloom was initially against the idea. "They were the usual reasons that people always frighten you with," Bloom says. "That she's been hothoused because she's been pushed, that she wouldn't be able to make friends and the really big furphy that she couldn't go drinking with her friends - as if her life depended on that!"
But the principal showed her a long list of pros and a very short list of cons, so after only two weeks in Year 1, Jessica started studying Year 3. Now 14, Jessica will finish her Higher School Certificate next year at the tender age of 16 1/2 and her parents have never regretted advancing her.
With apologies to those few and rare parents of true prodigies, this whole issue has been hopelessly corrupted by the fact that “gifted’ has become the adjective of choice for dysfunctional parents and therapists describing troubled, underachieving children. Few proud, serious parents would describe their accomplished children this way, if only for fear the little nits would get swelled heads and slack off.
With today's education system of teaching mediocrity (instead of teaching up, teachers often teach down), getting a child into a gifted program is sometimes the only way to get a bright child (not necessarily gifted, but above average) into more advanced classes with more challenging curriculum.
It's a pretty sad commentary, but the state of public education is pretty sad.
Posted by: Anne at March 6, 2006 9:31 PMAnne, Quite the understatement.
Posted by: erp at March 6, 2006 11:39 PMOne thing I note from my own experience is that none of the top graduates from high school were in the elementary school gifted classes, and all of the elementary gifted students were decidedly second tier or lower in high school. Not sure if that experience holds for other schools. It would be an interesting comparison.
Posted by: Chris Durnell at March 7, 2006 11:56 AM