January 26, 2006
MAKE US TAKE THE MONEY OUT OF OUR OWN POCKETS:
The Fix-It Myth (Robert J. Samuelson, January 26, 2006, Washington Post)
Almost everyone agrees that we ought to "fix the health care system" -- a completely meaningless phrase despite its popularity with politicians, pundits and "experts." Indeed, it is popular precisely because it is meaningless. The people who proclaim it rarely tell you the discomforting choices it might involve. Instead, they focus on a few specific shortcomings of our $1.9 trillion health-industrial complex and imply that, if we correct these often serious flaws, we'll have "fixed" the system or at least made a good start. This is rarely true, and so most forays into "health reform" end with disillusion.We are about to start the cycle again. By most accounts, President Bush plans to highlight health care in his forthcoming State of the Union address. His proposals may or may not have merit, but they surely won't fix the health system in any fundamental way. The reason is that most Americans don't want to fix the system in that sense. Most are satisfied with their care. Most don't see (or directly pay) the vast majority of their costs. Because politicians -- of both parties -- reflect public opinion, they won't do more than tinker.
Unfortunately, tinkering isn't enough.
The fundamental flaw in the system is that we don't see or pay the costs, a flaw that HSA's -- and only HSA's -- are designed to remedy. Posted by Orrin Judd at January 26, 2006 3:22 PM
Mickey Kaus once wondered why medical insurance and bills shouldn't be the most expensive part of an individuals budget. I agree.
Posted by: Pepys at January 26, 2006 5:46 PMYou see the costs when you don't have "insurance" to pay for it for you, and you aren't poor enough for the Gov't to do it either.
A few months ago I had a little problem that I knew needed treatment with antibiotics, and might need a little cutting. Luckily, the latter wasn't necessary, but after factoring how much paying for the doc to sign the paper added in, I ended up paying over$20 a pill. Then again, since that's my first encounter with the medical-industrial complex tin his century, so it cost me a lot less than "health insurance" would have.
Posted by: Raoul Ortega at January 26, 2006 6:22 PM