January 16, 2006
LOST IN THE ENCHANTED KINGDOM
Psychotherapy on the Road to ... Where? (Benedict Carey, New York Times, December 27th, 2005)
The meeting brought together some 9,000 psychologists, social workers and students, along with many of the world's most celebrated living therapists, among them the psychoanalyst Dr. Otto Kernberg, the Hungarian-born psychiatrist and skeptic Dr. Thomas Szasz, and Dr. Albert Bandura, the pioneer in self-directed behavior change."This is like a rock concert for most of us," said Peggy Fitzgerald, 56, a social worker and teacher from Sacramento, holding up a program covered in autographs. Ms. Fitzgerald said she attended war protests during the 1960's, and "this has some of that same feeling."
Calls to arms rang through several conference halls. In the opening convocation, Dr. Hunter "Patch" Adams - the charismatic therapist played on screen by Robin Williams - displayed on a giant projection screen photos from around the world of burned children, starving children, diseased children, some lying in their own filth.
He called for a "last stand of loving care" to prevail over the misery in the world, its wars and "our fascistic government." Overcome by his own message, Dr. Adams eventually fell to the floor of the stage in tears.
Many in the audience of thousands were deeply moved; many others were bewildered. Some left the arena. [...]
A frequent theme of the meeting was that therapists could not only relieve anxieties and despair but help clients realize a truly fulfilling life - an idea based on emerging research.
In his talk, Dr. Seligman spelled out the principles of this vision, called positive psychology. By learning to express gratitude, to savor the day's pleasures and to nurture native strengths, a people can become more absorbed in their daily lives and satisfied with them, his research has suggested.
A just-completed study at the University of Pennsylvania found that these techniques relieved the symptoms of depression better than other widely applied therapies, Dr. Seligman told the audience.
"The zeit is really geisting on this idea right now," said Dr. Seligman, who has consulted with the military on how to incorporate his methods.
Indeed it is. In fact, it has been geisting on that idea for over five thousand years. But we hope Dr. Seligman won’t be offended if we suggest it doesn’t geist all that well in the hands of infantile neurotics who charge us three hundred dollars an hour to share the insights into the mystery of life they learned from Mr Toad’s Wild Ride.
Posted by Peter Burnet at January 16, 2006 6:10 AMPsychotherapy is what New Yorkers rent in an effort to replace a functioning family.
Posted by: ZF at January 16, 2006 7:28 AMThat is just sad - are you sure it's not a satire?
Posted by: Mike Beversluis at January 16, 2006 8:14 AM"people can become more absorbed in their daily lives..."
Because heaven knows we have a shortage of that.
Posted by: Rick T. at January 16, 2006 9:13 AMPatch Adams is quite possibly the worst movie that I have ever seen. Horrible stuff...
Posted by: b at January 16, 2006 10:33 AMI think I liked Robin Williams better than the real thing. Obviously, Patch overlooked the Shiites' and Kurd's children in his labeling our government "Fascistic." I guess he prefers live and let live, regardless.
Posted by: Genecis at January 16, 2006 10:37 AMWell, Dr Seligman represents quite a lot of progress over the first hundred years of psychotherapy. In fifty years, I have hope that a ground-breaking psychotherapist will teach us that the best way of living is to "love one another."
Posted by: pj at January 16, 2006 11:35 AM--In his talk, Dr. Seligman spelled out the principles of this vision, called positive psychology. By learning to express gratitude, to savor the day's pleasures and to nurture native strengths, a people can become more absorbed in their daily lives and satisfied with them, his research has suggested. --
He's suggesting they become conservative/republican?????
Posted by: Sandy P at January 16, 2006 6:09 PMIn the opening convocation, Dr. Hunter "Patch" Adams [...] called for a "last stand of loving care" to prevail over the misery in the world, its wars and "our fascistic government." Overcome by his own message, Dr. Adams eventually fell to the floor of the stage in tears.
If you have a minute, be sure to read what he said during his visit to Cuba. He's a regular holiday fruitcake.
Posted by: Matt Murphy at January 16, 2006 7:53 PMSandy P -
Martin E. P. Seligman is a disciple of Carl Jung, not Siggie. As such, he believes in god, the human soul and personal responsibility ... all of those ideas having been rejected by Freud. Seligman's views are pretty much consistent with those expressed by Rick Warren in "The Purpose-Driven Life". Heck, Seligman's views of mental illness are close to oj's !
Posted by: ghostcat at January 16, 2006 10:57 PMBut where does he stand on trains????
Posted by: Sandy P at January 17, 2006 12:21 AM