January 9, 2006

BACK WHEN AN IVY PEDIGREE WAS A STRIKE:

Proving His Mettle in the Reagan Justice Dept. (Jo Becker and Dale Russakoff, January 9, 2006, Washington Post)

The captains of the Reagan revolution at the Justice Department had two big concerns about a bookish new recruit named Samuel A. Alito Jr., who arrived in 1981: his blank slate as a conservative activist and his pedigree from a perceived bastion of legal liberalism.

"I wouldn't let most people from Yale Law School wash my car, let alone write my briefs," said Michael A. Carvin, a political deputy at the department.


Ah, the good old days, before the conservatives became intellectualized and elitist.

Posted by Orrin Judd at January 9, 2006 8:35 AM
Comments

Actually, this might just be a knock on Yale. I was the hiring partner at a major law firm for a number of years. We typically hired our associates from the Top 15 or 20 law schools. The kids rom Harvard, Columbia, Boalt Hall, UCLA, Texas, NYU, etc. were typically terrific: bright and eager with good research and writing skills and a modicum of business sense. The kids from Yale were a disaster: arrogant, no interest in being practical, and not particulary good writers.
I don't know if that was a result of the types of students they accepted or a product of the Yale Law curriculum, but it was a consistent phenomenon. (Of course, the logical question is "Then why did you keep hiring Yale kids?" And the answer is because one of our managing partners was a Yale grad, and he would unilaterally make summer clerk offers to Yale students. Thankfully, none of them ever came back to the firm after graduation.)

Posted by: Foos at January 9, 2006 11:23 AM

You know, I like Alito. I like him a lot. He'll probably be a better judge than Miers. But there's some remarkable unintentionally hilarious stuff out there from some Anti-Miers folk. Consider Ramesh Ponnuru today, just now:

I thought Alito did well. I don't think he told that opening anecdote very smoothly, but that's okay: To the extent his remarks lacked polish, they drew sympathy and helped his basic I'm-one-of-you message.

Posted by: Timothy at January 9, 2006 5:38 PM

Put out the torch OJ.

Posted by: Robert Schwartz at January 10, 2006 12:28 AM
« INDEPENDENCE DAZE: | Main | PIANO PLAYERISM: »