November 12, 2005
HELP!
So, all you shut-ins: if an 8 year old boy wants a video game player for Christmas, and his parents are cheap, what would you recommend?
Thanks,
Griffin Judd
MORE:
Xbox Shoots for Next Level: Microsoft's new game console has a head start on Sony's PlayStation 3. The stakes are high. (Julie Tamaki, November 13, 2005, LA Times)
Andrew Martin recently flew from his home in Florida to New York and stayed in a $400-a-night hotel — all to play video games.And Bill Gates picked up the tab.
A 24-year-old English major, Martin is considered a tastemaker among a group that Microsoft Corp. is sparing little expense to woo: hard-core video game enthusiasts.
Martin has posted more than 10,000 messages about video games on the Internet, so Microsoft considered his opinions key to generating positive buzz about its Xbox 360 game console.
As the software powerhouse readies the $399 console for release Nov. 22, the praise of gamers like Martin may give Microsoft the edge it needs to overtake market leader Sony Corp. in the $25-billion global game business.
"I played it and thought: Wow," Martin said of a horror game that topped a favorable Xbox 360 write-up he posted online. "I wasn't expecting there to be good games right away."
$400? Posted by Orrin Judd at November 12, 2005 4:25 PM
the players are cheapish, it's the games that will cost you the real money. has he sampled all the free games available on the internet ? you play these using a web browser.
Posted by: a dad at November 12, 2005 4:48 PMAs a father of 19-year old and 18-year old I recommend to buy some great adventure books instead.
Jules Verne, Jack London and many others.
Video game player IS an de-socializer, a tool for stupefing and mind numbing, time waster.
Children should play outside of the house instead of spending hours on mental garbage - just look at the content of the most popular video games.
It is as bad as a Playboy would be for 7 year olds.
Posted by: sushizero at November 12, 2005 4:55 PMBuy him an old school original Nintendo. Nothing beats the classics.
Posted by: andrew at November 12, 2005 4:55 PMMultiple Arcade Machine Emulator. Price: $0.00
Posted by: Gideon at November 12, 2005 5:23 PMDid I just get insulted by an 8 year old?
Posted by: pepys at November 12, 2005 5:49 PMDon't by the anti-game fuddy-duddys. Your kid will game at friends'houses, he will get together with multiple buds for gaming, this is a tsunami force desire that will overwhelm your suspicions unless you live far out in the woods in isolation from people and electricity.
What you can do is limit gaming. At my house, the limits were these: no gaming on school nights, otherwise homework gets rushed through to get to gaming, which, by the way, is completely b*tchin'. On weekends, there is a correlation between gaming time and reading time, at eight it was 1/2 hour reading = 1 hour gaming; then it became 1:1 somewhere around 10 or 11 years of age. Now, my fifteen year old is too busy with sports and friends to spend more than a couple of hours a week gaming and it is always with friends. No big whoop.
All the gaming platforms are cheap if you think about the hours of complete enjoyment they deliver. Just my opinion.
Posted by: Palmcroft at November 12, 2005 6:06 PMThe new game sets are coming out soon. See if you can get a used set and the games from someone looking to trade up. You should be able to get a good deal.
Posted by: Robert Mitchell Jr. at November 12, 2005 6:16 PMThere are flots of stores specalizing in used/remanufactured sets, and secondhand games (no national chains, so far as I know); you can get a steep discount there. If you must buy new games, many of the consoles have last couple years' most successful titles available at discount; these are usually above-average games anyway.
Nintendo, and to a lesser extent PS1/2, tend to be the ones with games targeted to preteens.
Posted by: Mike Earl at November 12, 2005 6:42 PMA word from an old granny. Computer games are part of life for kids today. Why make your kid an oddball for a couple of hundred bucks? Unless the family budget simply can’t handle it, it’s really money well spent.
… and Griffin (my grandson’s name too), if all else fails, simply whisper it in your grandmother’s ear. Never fails.
Posted by: erp at November 12, 2005 6:57 PMGood points above. An 8 yr old probably doesn't need cutting edge so getting slightly outdated models is a good option. And it's the games that drive the cost up.
When Nintendo came out with Gamecube a friend of mine went to ebay and got a Nintendo 64 (the version being upgraded from)and about 40 games for $50.
Another option - if you have friends whose kids are 10 or over they are probably ready to get rid of the "baby" games so you might pick up a bunch of games that way.
Griffin -
I have an 8 year old son as well. *LOVES* the video games. Tell your cheapskate dad to pick up a Sony Playstation 2 (~ $180) and by _used_ video games which is where the real cost comes in ($50 new, $7 to $15 used). If you can find a used Playstation 2, so much the better.
Posted by: Bruce Cleaver at November 12, 2005 7:59 PMGriffin -- These games are big timewasters. A video gameplayer was one of the few items we denied our son. Shocking, I know, but it hardly made him a social pariah. He whined and pouted off-and-on for years and, yes, he did do end-runs around his parents at Halo marathons organized by his friends. But now that he's at college, he doesn't have the habit like his friends do, and he's actually thanked us for holding firm. It can be done.
Posted by: Melissa at November 12, 2005 8:02 PMMelissa, Your college age kid thanked you for holding firm. Wow! You really must be some kind of mother.
Posted by: erp at November 12, 2005 8:19 PMTell your dad that you need this instead Gas is only a couple of bucks per gallon.
Posted by: h-man at November 12, 2005 10:38 PMI would agree with AWW. Find something, anything, used on EBay.
Posted by: HT at November 13, 2005 12:05 AM
Get him one of the "Civilization" games for the computer. You'll play it more than him. You can pound on the continentals with the Anglosphere. I bought Civilization III a few years ago, but Civ 4 just came out.
Posted by: Matt Cohen at November 13, 2005 12:51 AMCivilzation may be a bit heavy for the average 8 yr old, but when I was 12 it was addictive. (Hint: Exploit the invention of the railroad mercilessly.)
Posted by: Gideon at November 13, 2005 2:01 AMI cannot believe in a post about inexpensive videogames on a blog populated by conservatives who have a deep respect for tradition, we have gone 18 comments into this thread without anybody mentioning Nintendo Tecmo Super Bowl.
Andrew's right: The classics have much to teach us.
Posted by: Matt Murphy at November 13, 2005 3:22 AMBuy him a BB gun instead.
Posted by: AllenS at November 13, 2005 4:52 AMI was never much into gaming, but I did recently buy myself the Atari Flashback 2. I got the older model for my brother. It's inferior in several ways, but I've found the gameplay on the the AF2 frustrating so far. I think I'd be happier with a NES on a chip system than the Atari though. MAME could do this for me, but I wanted a console.
Posted by: RC at November 13, 2005 6:16 AMYou can go with the soon to replaced playstation 2 or Xbox. You should be able to find it pretty cheap. Then, you don't even have to buy games. A co-worker of mine uses a service called gamefy.com. It's basically netflix for video games.
Posted by: mc at November 13, 2005 7:13 AM1) I've actually thanked my parents for holding firm on certain things in my youth.
2) I tried getting Orrin into Civilization, but he hates it because you can have Communism as a viable economy.
3) MAME is awesome, but it can be hard to get ROMs for since mame.dk got shut down.
4) Griffin, tell your dad to look for a used Nintendo Gamecube. If he waits until the new Nintendo Revolution system comes out, he will be able to pick up the Gamecube real cheap plus lots of games. Also Nintendo has more games designed for children, as opposed to the X-Box which is aimed at beer-swilling fratboys like your ogre of a father.
Griffen:
Listen to Bryan. Nintendo Game Cube is best by far. And Andrew strongly recommends NHL 2006 for endless hours of fun. If your dad tries to tell you that would be unpatriotic, tell him he can be the Zamboni driver.
Posted by: Peter B at November 13, 2005 7:28 AMGriffin:
Tell your dad you want a BB gun, slingshot and a boomerang.
Posted by: AllenS at November 13, 2005 7:29 AMGriffen:
I agree with my dad for once, but Mario Power Tennis and Mario Superstar Baseball are also terrific. Hey, when are you guys coming up here?
Andrew
Posted by: Peter B at November 13, 2005 7:40 AMSo, from what I'm hearing--I can tell the little stinker that the old Nintendo 64 that his cousins gave him is just fine, as long as we get some games for it, and our rules limiting use to two hours on weekends are reasonable?
How about that and a Gameboy, twerp?
Posted by: oj at November 13, 2005 8:20 AMSure, keep the Nintendo 64. It will go great with his hi fi and black and white TV. C'mon, Scrooge, just dip into your private social security account and get the Game Cube.
The rule is very reasonable. Watching you try and enforce it will give us hours of mirth.
Posted by: Peter B at November 13, 2005 8:27 AMI found Civilization for $1 at the local Salvation Army Thrift Store but I can't figure out how to play it.
Posted by: oj at November 13, 2005 9:11 AMGet a Nintendo GameCube. The games are much more children friendly and you can pick up used games pretty easily. Plus, the Madden Football and the baseball ones are really good.
My son loved the old Nintendo 64 until it died, but as time goes by, these are harder to find. I don't like Gameboys because it is harder to control usage and I can't stand the slack jawed look of kids playing these things anywhere, anytime. However, when you have to go do something, and they'd rather not be there, it does keep them busy. But, please, don't bring it to church.
No GameCube during the week and a limit on the weekend is a good rule of thumb. Plus, nothing strikes fear in the heart of a 7 year old (my son) like the threat of losing that precious gaming time.
Posted by: Buttercup at November 13, 2005 9:29 AMButtercup:
It is a good rule of thumb. And, of course, Griffin has the ideal role model to teach him to exercise discipline and restraint in the use of computers, etc.
Posted by: Peter B at November 13, 2005 10:06 AMJust like to second that, as noted above, Nintendo seems to have more young kid games (i.e. rated E) than the others. And yes game use must be controlled but I feel ok if the kid is spending 1 hour playing Animal Crossing or Harvest Moon (where you build and control cities/farms with people like animals) or Pikman (very mild alien game) instead of Duke Nukem or
Doom or whatever the latest all death game is.
Hey, Griffin, let me know what kind of game box you get so I can send you a driving wheel. It's never to early to learn to love the automobile! My little monkeys were driving virtual semis down Lake Shore Drive at 90 MPH by the time they were three.
Sorry, OJ, I completely misread your e-mail. I can't help because She Who Is Perfect In All Ways has forbidden game boxes in the house. Even I can't have one.
Posted by: Annoying Old Guy at November 13, 2005 8:35 PMI've still got my old Civilization player's guide "Rome on 640K a Day" around here somewhere.
Posted by: Bryan at November 14, 2005 12:19 AMI used to spend hours every weekend, during the early 80s, playing the original Civilization board game with my friends.
Then, '94 - '95 were "The Years of Sid Miers' Civilization", where I played maybe twenty hours a week.
As one might expect, I got pretty good at it.
Gideon is correct, at least for the first version: Railroads are key. Put them in every hex.
However, although I've noted the newer versions coming out with interest and nostalgia, I haven't picked 'em up, nor played since '95.
The wisdom of middle age has revealed this to me:
Videogames are a (very pleasurable) waste of time. Even the strategy ones, although those do teach, as well.
They should be lumped in with television-watching time, and an umbrella weekly limit set.
Posted by: Michael Herdegen at November 14, 2005 7:35 AM