September 27, 2005

NEVER FLY A THIRD WORLD PLANE:

A Skeptic Under Pressure: A U.S. engineer faces bankruptcy and arrest in Austria as he questions the safety of a component in the huge Airbus A380 jetliner. (Peter Pae, September 27, 2005, LA Times)

Joseph Mangan, 41, is a whistle-blower. As a result he and his family find themselves in a foreign country with unfamiliar laws, fighting a legal battle that has left them almost penniless.

A year ago, Mangan told European aviation authorities that he believed there were problems with a computer chip on the Airbus A380, the biggest and costliest commercial airliner ever built. The A380 is a double-decked engineering marvel that will carry as many as 800 passengers — double the capacity of Boeing Co.'s 747. It is expected to enter airline service next year.

Mangan alleges that flaws in a microprocessor could cause the valves that maintain cabin pressure on the A380 to accidentally open during flight, allowing air to leak out so rapidly that everyone aboard could lose consciousness within seconds.

It's a lethal scenario similar to the 1999 crash that killed professional golfer Payne Stewart and five others when their Learjet lost cabin pressure and they blacked out. The plane flew on autopilot for hours before crashing in South Dakota.

Mangan was chief engineer for TTTech Computertechnik, a Viennese company that supplies the computer chips and software to control the cabin-pressurization system for the A380, which is being assembled at the Airbus plant in France.

In October, TTTech fired Mangan and filed civil and criminal charges against him for revealing company documents. The company said the information was proprietary and he had no right to disclose it to anyone.

Mangan countersued, saying he had been wrongly terminated for raising legitimate safety concerns.

Unlike U.S. laws that shield whistle-blowers from corporate retaliation, Austrian laws offer no such protection. Last year an Austrian judge imposed an unusual gag order on Mangan, seeking to stop him from talking about the case.

Mangan posted details about the case anyway in his own Internet blog. The Austrian court fined him $185,000 for violating the injunction.

And the Vienna police, who are conducting a criminal investigation into the matter, searched the family's apartment for four hours, downloading files from Mangan's computer as his children watched.

Posted by Orrin Judd at September 27, 2005 11:51 AM
Comments

Also from the article: "Throughout the family's ordeal, Mangan remained dogmatic about not being chased out of Austria and about standing up for what he believed in. Diana said that she wondered at times whether it might be better to move on, but that the family was "very supportive that it will all work out.""

I dunno about the accuracy of his claims, but he sure sounds a bit off if he's willing to put his family through all this instead of just coming back to the US and trying to start over with another aerospace company. Heck, he can still keep his blog and spread the word from there...

Posted by: at September 27, 2005 12:47 PM

Bye bye Airbus?

Posted by: erp at September 27, 2005 12:48 PM

Seems a bit too curious a story, if you ask me.

So far, the only (solid) problem I have seen with the A380 on various aviation websites is that the landing gear tends to bump and scrape the well(s) when they are retracted.

Posted by: jim hamlen at September 27, 2005 1:59 PM

I just read in the news that there was an accident in Japan on All Nippon Airways (ANA) which uses all Airbus aircrafts. The reason was very similar to what Ms. Mangan was afraid could happen to the Airbus A380 jetliner.

Posted by: aska at September 29, 2005 6:20 PM

Has anyone found the URL to Joseph's blog that was mentioned in the article ? be good to hear the story direct from the source and what exactly is flawed about the chip

Posted by: Andy at October 1, 2005 8:22 PM

His site seems to just have gone online at www.joe-mangan.com

A modern day hero, if you ask me. Feel bad for the kids and would be proud to have a wife that stands behind a guy like this. Lost all the material stuff!!

We need to treat our heroes with respect and take care of the few that we have.

Posted by: Michael Glatz at October 6, 2005 10:11 AM
« GO PBS: | Main | LESS REFORM, PLEASE, WE'RE CONTINENTAL: »