July 28, 2005
FAILING GRADE (via Jeff Brokaw):
Now for the good news (Lexington, Jul 21st 2005, The Economist)
THERE is no shortage of bad news for the White House these days. The Washington press corps is on death watch outside the house of Karl Rove, George Bush's chief adviser, and the car bombs continue to explode across Iraq. Yet last Thursday also saw some rare good news. It is buried in a pretty obscure place, in a report published by the National Assessment of Educational Progress. But it has some big implications—not only for Mr Bush's much-maligned claim that he is a different sort of conservative, but also for the future health of American society.The National Assessment of Educational Progress has been periodically testing a representative sample of 9-, 13- and 17-year-olds since the early 1970s. This year's report contained two striking results. The first is that America's nine-year-olds posted their best scores in reading and maths since the tests were introduced (in 1971 in reading and 1973 in maths). The second is that the gap between white students and minorities is narrowing. The nine-year-olds who made the biggest gains of all were blacks, traditionally the most educationally deprived group in American society.
The education establishment—particularly the two big teachers' unions—were quick to pooh-pooh the result. The critics argued that Mr Bush cannot take credit for the gains because his chief educational reform, the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Act, had been in place for only a year when the tests were administered. They also pointed out that the gains are not universal. The results are mixed for 13-year-olds and 17-year-olds. The reading skills of black and Latino 17-year-olds were nearly identical to those of white 13-year-olds.
All this is true, but self-confounding. Mr Bush's act may be very new. But the ideas that lie behind it—focusing on basic subjects such as maths and reading and using regular testing to hold schools accountable—have been widely tried at the state level since at least the mid-1990s. Mr Bush deserves credit for recognising winning ideas thrown up by America's “laboratories of democracy” and then applying them at the federal level.
John Kerry and the Democrats managed to do something truly incredible--they helped pass NCLB for the President but then ran against it in November, just before it was conclusively shown to be working. Their hatred of George Bush has deranged them. Posted by Orrin Judd at July 28, 2005 2:47 PM
They ran against it because they knew it was working. The last thing the teachers unions or their handmaidens, Democrat politicians want is an informed and knowledgeable citizenry.
Posted by: erp at July 28, 2005 5:23 PMWhen black votes Republican then I believe that it's working.
Posted by: Lan Nguyen at July 28, 2005 10:06 PMln, not sure i follow your point, care to expand a bit ?