May 12, 2005
BURN, BABY, BURN:
What's Yalta Got to Do With It?: Bush rehashes history and revisits the lessons of the Soviet scourge (Howard Fineman, May 11, 2005, Newsweek)
Boy, it's been a long time since Yalta made news—a half century or so. And yet if George W. Bush's trip to Europe is to be remembered for anything, it will be for the incendiary speech about Yalta he gave in Riga, Latvia, accusing FDR and Churchill of having agreed at the Crimean summit in 1945 to abandon Eastern Europe to Soviet communism.Anybody who was surprised at Bush's audacity doesn't understand his presidency—how it sees the world, who it cares about (or doesn't care about), how it operates diplomatically and politically.
I recently spent some time at the White House visiting with Mike Gerson, the president's speechwriter. In his self-deprecating, elliptical fashion, Gerson told me he was working on a draft for the Europe trip. He was spending a lot of time on it. The president obviously thought it was important. Gerson didn't say that his boss was going to throw a Molotov cocktail at the entire tradition of Big Power, post-war diplomacy. I should have expected it.
As we're fond of saying, no President has ever confused his opponents more thoroughly by being so utterly predictable. Posted by Orrin Judd at May 12, 2005 4:41 PM
The speech will be remembered as an admirable moment by the people whose memories don't usually associate Molotov with a cocktail but as a henchman for an evil empire. Those who prefer cocktails, or Che! t-shirts, or the disgraceful tradition of post-war diplomacy will of course swoon, simper, or snipe. PS - Gerson played you, Howard.
Posted by: Luciferous at May 12, 2005 5:24 PM"Gerson didn't say that his boss was going to throw a Molotov cocktail at the entire tradition of Big Power, post-war diplomacy."
Molotov was on the Central Committee at the time of Yalta. No cocktails for him.
Posted by: Robert Schwartz at May 12, 2005 10:31 PM
More On Molotov from Wikepedia:
Vyacheslav Mikhaylovich Molotov (1890 -- 1986) and Joseph Stalin were the only senior revolutionary Bolsheviks to survive the Great Purges of the 1930s.
He was born in the village of Kukarka (now Sovetsk in Kirov Oblast), Russia, as Vyacheslav Mikhaylovich Skryabin. He joined the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party in 1906 and took the pseudonym Molotov (Russian: hammer). He was, along with Alexander Shlyapnikov, the senior Bolshevik in Petrograd at the time of the February Revolution as figures such as Lenin were still in exile. After what appears to be an odyssey through the landscape of geographic and political Russia including an important role in the October Revolution and editing the newspaper Pravda for a while, he started working under Joseph Stalin in 1922.
From December 19, 1930 to May 9, 1941, he was Chairman of the Council of People's Commissars, in which capacity he was the head of government of the USSR, although this position was in practice subordinate to the General Secretary of the Communist Party, Stalin.
In May 1939 he became People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs (Foreign Minister), and he held both positions until Stalin took over the head of government role two years later. It is believed that he was made foreign minister because his predecessor, Maxim Litvinov, was Jewish, and might thus have insulted the Germans by his role in negotiations. Molotov negotiated in parallel with both the West and Nazis to secure maximal territorial gain for Soviet Union. After British-French-Soviet talks held in August of 1939 failed, he negotiated the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact with his German counterpart, Joachim von Ribbentrop. In accordance with the pact, the Soviet Union invaded Poland on September 17, 1939, after it had already been invaded from the west by Germany on September 1, and subsequently annexed the eastern part of the country. For the citizens of eastern Poland, this meant the beginning of mass arrests and deportations of "class enemies" to the eastern part of the Soviet Union. During this period, Molotov publicly expressed his satisfaction at the fall of Poland under both German and Soviet onslaughts, blaming the Polish state and its "landlords' rule" for the oppression of ethnic minorities.
As a member of the Soviet politburo, Molotov approved executions. For example, on March 5, 1940, the politburo signed an order of execution (prepared by Lavrenti Beria) of 25,700 members of the Polish intelligentsia, including 14,700 Polish prisoners of war -- the Katyn massacre.
During the period prior to the outbreak of war between the USSR and Germany in 1941, Molotov consistently annoyed the Germans with his pragmatic tenacity during negotiations, insisting on preserving or advancing Soviet interests in Eastern Europe, and not being deceived by idle German promises of concessions in other faraway parts of the world, such as India. (According to a story later told by Stalin to Winston Churchill, when Ribbentrop was discussing dividing up the spoils of a soon-to-be-conquered British Empire, Molotov once responded by asking him why, if Britain was doomed, were they holding negotiations in an air raid shelter.)
Molotov served as foreign minister until 1949, when he was replaced by Andrei Vyshinsky as a mark of falling out of Stalin's favor, and he was removed from the Politburo in 1952. His wife Polina Zhemchuzhina, a staunch Zionist and friend of Golda Meir, was arrested for treason in 1948 during what some have termed an anti-Semitic campaign against "rootless cosmopolitans".
For reasons such as these, some have speculated that Molotov could have become a victim of a purge Stalin was suspected of planning in the last weeks of his life. Following Stalin's death in 1953, he was reinstated in the Politburo (which was now called the Presidium) and served again as foreign minister until 1956, but soon found himself at odds with the reformist policies of Stalin's eventual successor, Nikita Khrushchev, and was strongly opposed to Khrushchev's 1956 denunciation of Stalin.
In 1957, along with other top Stalinists such as Lazar Kaganovich (the so-called Anti-Party Group), he attempted a coup within the party to oust Khrushchev. When this failed, it provided Khrushchev with a pretext to demote Molotov to a series of increasingly irrelevant posts: first as Ambassador to Mongolia (1957–1960) and then as the permanent Soviet delegate to the International Atomic Energy Agency in Vienna (1960–1961). By 1964, he had been expelled from the party altogether.
Molotov was allowed to rejoin the party in 1984, but this was a purely symbolic gesture. At the time of his death at the age of 96 in Moscow on November 8, 1986, he was the last surviving major participant in the events of 1917. He was buried at the Novodevichy Cemetery, Moscow.
Soldiers of the Finnish Army mockingly named the Molotov cocktail after him, as Molotov served as the Commissar for Foreign Affairs during the time of the Russo-Finnish War (1939–1940).
Posted by: Robert Schwartz at May 12, 2005 10:43 PMLet me get this right: We buried the bastards after 80 years of struggle, smashed their jailhouse of nations into tiny shards and now we're to be careful not to hurt their feelings?
Posted by: Lou Gots at May 13, 2005 9:39 PMLet me get this right: We buried the bastards after 80 years of struggle, smashed their jailhouse of nations into tiny shards and now we're to be careful not to hurt their feelings?
Posted by: Lou Gots at May 13, 2005 9:39 PM