March 13, 2005

THE WAGES OF REALISM

These Irish eyes are smiling at White House snub of IRA (Mark Steyn, Chicago Sun-Times, March 13th, 2005)

There's a lesson there in the reformability of terrorists. The IRA's first instinct is to kill. If you complain about the killing, they offer to kill the killers. If you complain about the manner of the killing, they offer to kill more tastefully -- "compassionate terrorism,'' as it were. But it's like Monty Python's spam sketch: There's no menu item that doesn't involve killing. You can get it in any color as long as it's blood-red.

For the last 3-1/2 years one of the most persistent streams of correspondence I've had is from British readers sneering, ''Oh-ho. So America's now waging a war on 'terror,' is she? Well, where were the bloody Yanks the last 30 years? Passing round the collection box for IRA donations in the bars of Boston and New York, that's where.''

They have a point. Blowing up grannies and schoolkids at bus stops is always wrong, and the misty shamrock-hued sentimentalization of it in this particular manifestation speaks poorly for America, the principal source for decades of IRA funding. On the other hand, it was the London and Dublin governments, not Washington, that decided they were going to accommodate the IRA, Her Majesty's government going so far at one point as to install Gerry Adams and his colleagues in the coalition administration of Northern Ireland, making IRA terrorists ministers of a crown they don't even deign to recognize.

Now Tony Blair & Co. profess to be shocked to discover that the leopard hasn't changed his spots. But, until January, if you raised the IRA's vicious methods of retribution against dissident Catholics, British officials would chortle urbanely and assure you it was just a little ''internal housekeeping'' by Adams and his chums.

So London and Dublin have only themselves to blame for the present situation. By enhancing the prestige of the terrorists, they've enabled Sinn Fein to supplant moderate Catholic political parties in both Northern and Southern Ireland. Because they no longer have to engage in the costly and time-consuming business of waging war against the British Army, they've been free to convert themselves into the emerald isle's answer to the Russian Mafia. They recently pulled off the biggest bank heist in British history -- snaffling just shy of 50 million bucks from the vaults of Ulster's Northern Bank. What do they need that money for? Well, it helps them fund their real objective: the takeover of southern Ireland.

In hindsight, the '90s were the apogee of terrorist mainstreaming, with Yasser and Gerry given greater access to the White House than your average prime minister of a friendly middle-rank power. And in return for what? Nothing other than the corrosive impact on weak-willed Westerners desperate to believe that all terrorists can somehow be accommodated if you just roll out the red carpet for them. Witness Robert McNamara, the Kennedy/Johnson defense secretary who popped up last week with a particularly fatuous observation even by his own standards: As Associated Press reported, ''McNamara added that the threat of terrorists using a nuclear device could be reduced if the United States in particular tried to understand terrorists' anger and motivations.''

Since Vietnam, countless leftist and realist Western leaders have been seduced by the dream of grand reconciliations with dangerous, sworn enemies. The lure of these devils’ pacts is their promise of peace, but all they ever seem to bring is death to the decent, the alienation of allies and the destruction of democratic forces.


Posted by Peter Burnet at March 13, 2005 7:13 AM
Comments

The IRA have always been Hamas-like terrorists of the worst order. It is only the power of alcohol that has kept them from greater depredations than they have already committed. Americans, logically offended and disgusted by Britain's vicious history in Ireland, have been swindled into contributing money to IRA coffers for decades. Irish governments and the Catholic Church have done a very poor job presenting people of otherwise goodwill from having an alternate framework to contribute to Irish national unity. One of the drearier results of the New Testament is the permanence of a 'peace at any price' lobby throughout Christendom.

BTW, at some point doesn't even McNamara have to develop even the merest capacity for circumspection after his staggeringly dreadful track record?

Posted by: Bart at March 13, 2005 8:06 AM

Don't you two get OJ's memo? Hamas and Hezbollah are normal political parties on the make anyway.

I agree with very little of Steyn's argument. While Sinn Fein has passed the SLDP as the main nationalist party in the Six Counties, it has certainly not supplanted either Fianna Fail or Fine Gael in the Republic. Furthermore, Sinn Fein won those votes primarily on the basis of their work towards the peace process.

All parties in Nothern Ireland were content to let all terrorists (including the Loyalists responsible for more of the crime and terrorism nowadays) "police" their own communities. The problem with Steyn and the rest of the media is that they concentrate exclusively on the IRA as if their elimination will magically create peace. All it will do is monopolize terror to the Loyalist side.

The response of the nationalists, of course, will be to look towards its own defense again and a new IRA will be born, but this time there won't be anyone with the credentials of a Gerry Adams to move the whole thing to peace. Regardless of how much blood one thinks Adams has on his hands, he has done more than any other political figure to move towards peace in the past decade or two.

The criminality and murder in the IRA disgust me too, but I have not seen anyone analyze the situation by putting all terrorist parties into the equation. Instead there seems to be an assumption that the IRA is the only terrorist organization in Northern Ireland and if they're gone then there's peace. That is not the case.

The McCartney case, besides being a personal tragedy, is a public relations disaster for the IRA. People who don't know what they are talking about simply see this as an opportunity to ruin Sinn Fein. People who do know the situation instead are trying to figure out how to exploit it to further peace because the IRA is simply part of the problem, and any "solution" that does not take into account the Loyalist terrorists is not actually a solution.

Posted by: Chris Durnell at March 14, 2005 11:41 AM
« JON STEWART SYNDROME: | Main | WORTHWHILE: »