March 29, 2005
THE PARTY IN POWER GETS TO CAPITALIZE:
Leaders of the Opposition (NOAM SCHEIBER, 3/29/05, NY Times)
ACCORDING to a now infamous memo circulated among Republican senators, the Terri Schiavo case is a "great political issue" for their party. The memo is half right: the case may be good politics - but for Democrats. After all, in defending their intervention, Republican leaders in Congress have marshaled traditionally liberal arguments about the federal government's obligations to its citizens.Indeed, the practical effect of the idealistic arguments the Republican leadership puts forth to defend much of its agenda - from health care to education to immigration reform - may be to sell the middle of the electorate on longtime Democratic positions.
This phenomenon may be most pronounced in foreign policy, the president's defining issue. It is true that the president can claim that recent events in Lebanon, Egypt and even Kyrgyzstan vindicate his decision to invade Iraq, and so may bolster his party. If this trend toward democratization continues, however, Democrats may be better positioned to capitalize on it politically.
The reason is that - as with education, health care and immigration - promoting liberal democracy is a project Democrats have historically embraced.
You can almost pity folks like Mr. Scheiber who haven't figured out yet that its the Republicans not the Democrats who reflect their values. Posted by Orrin Judd at March 29, 2005 7:44 AM
Mr. Scheiber should direct his argument to his fellow democrats who have chosen the norms of the bath house over the state house.
Posted by: Luciferous at March 29, 2005 9:35 AMDon't the Democrats get any credit for having actually written the memo Mr. Scheiber bases his whole article upon?
Posted by: John at March 29, 2005 9:47 AMThe memo had the wrong bill number (S.529 not S.539), was taken verbatim including typos from a right-wing web site, and was never seen handed out by anyone on the Senate floor except Democrats.
(From PowerLine 5/23)
Posted by: Gideon at March 29, 2005 10:17 AM3/23/05
Posted by: Gideon at March 29, 2005 10:21 AMThose Evil Republicans would have done it if they could have, so even though that memo was "fake but accurate", that's all that matters. It's just another case of the Dems whipping themselves into a frenzy in their belief that the GOP is stealing from the Dem/Leftist playbook of dirty tricks.
Posted by: Raoul Ortega at March 29, 2005 1:20 PMThe reason is that - as with education, health care and immigration - promoting liberal democracy is a project Democrats have historically embraced.
Gee, haven't we covered this ground before?
(Hint: See OJ's last line.)
Posted by: Matt Murphy at March 29, 2005 9:23 PM