March 6, 2005

PILLARS OF SAND

Must democracy rest on faith? (Sophie Arie, Christian Science Monitor, March 6th, 2005)

Just as democracy is celebrating its first victories over tyranny and fear in the Middle East, one of its greatest advocates in the 20th century, Pope John Paul II, has issued a stark warning that self-rule does not always work.

In a new book published last week, "Memory and Identity: Conversations Between Millenniums," the pope attacks Western democratic society for being so obsessed with freedom that it has lost its sense of good and evil.

In the "negative" society of the West, the pope writes, "the principle to which people aspire is to think and act as if God did not exist."

There are such "enormous economic forces" behind the Western antigospel campaign, which supports divorce, free love, abortion, and euthanasia, that the Pope wonders whether the Western way of life is in fact a "new totalitarianism cunningly disguised as democracy."

He noted that it was a democratic parliament in Germany that allowed the election of Hitler in the 1930s. "We have to question the legal regulations that have been decided in the parliaments of present-day democracies," he wrote.

The book is the pope's fifth semiautobiographical publication. His first one sold 20 million copies.

By backing the Solidarity movement in his own country of Poland, the pope beckoned Poles to choose European democracy - an action that secured his place in history as a key figure behind the downfall of the Soviet Union. Now, he warns that Central and Eastern European countries are at risk of "falling without criticism under the influence of the negative culture so widespread in the West."

Perhaps the greatest fear in the Muslim world is that when they open the package that was supposed to contain Thomas Jefferson and George Washington, Paris Hilton and Jack Kevorkian will jump out.

Posted by Peter Burnet at March 6, 2005 10:52 AM
Comments

And who can blame them for their fear?

Posted by: Paul Cella at March 6, 2005 11:00 AM

Very good. The reality is that, without faith, one scratches Microsoft and one finds I.G. Farben. The pagan corporate culture is the culture of death, at both ends. Substuting immigration for reproduction is very, very good business, a theft of capital, if you will. Of course, the efficiency of dealing with life which is unworthy of life is too obvious.

Posted by: Lou Gots at March 6, 2005 11:57 AM

They will all pop out of course, human nature being what it is. Choices will then be made, many of them bad. Do you doubt that for a nanosecond?

Posted by: ghostcat at March 6, 2005 12:06 PM

Microsoft = I.G. Farben?? You religious types should really stay away from the deep end of the pool.

So are we for democracy, or not? The Pope may decry what happened under a democratic process in Germany in 1932, but atrocities had been happening in non-democratic Christian Europe for centuries, so what's his point?

Posted by: Robert Duquette at March 6, 2005 2:07 PM

Robert:

Jeff and Harry have taught you well. All pre-18th century history was not only controlled completely be religion, absolutely everything that happened was an expression of Christian faith and dogma. Not to mention that the everyone's behaviour was applied Christian theology by definition.

So, what is your point? Lots of atrocities happened in history, so we shouldn't sweat the modern ones?

Posted by: Peter B at March 6, 2005 4:41 PM

No, but going off half-cocked against Microsoft, and equating corporate cuture and the culture of death is pretty rich. Can't you guys even pretend to aim before you empty both barrels?

Posted by: Robert Duquette at March 6, 2005 5:05 PM
« WE LIKE DANCING, AND WE LOOK DIVINE: | Main | BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG LIES: »