February 13, 2005
RAINING ON THE LIBERTARIAN PARADE:
Neal Stephenson’s Past, Present, and Future: The author of the widely praised Baroque Cycle on science, markets, and post-9/11 America (Interviewed by Mike Godwin, February 2005, Reason)
Reason: Snow Crash is almost a parody of a libertarian future. Do you think the affinity-group-based societies you outline in that book are on their way? Do you see that as a warning note, or a natural state we’re progressing toward?Stephenson: I dreamed up the Snow Crash world 15 years ago as a thought experiment, and I tweaked it to be as funny and outrageous and graphic novel–like as I could make it. Such a world wouldn’t be stable unless each little “burbclave” had the ability to defend itself from all external threats. This is not plausible, barring some huge advances in defensive technology. So I think that if I were seriously to address your question, “Do you see that as a warning note, or a natural state…?,” I would be guilty of taking myself a little bit too seriously.
Speaking as an observer who has many friends with libertarian instincts, I would point out that terrorism is a much more formidable opponent of political liberty than government. Government acts almost as a recruiting station for libertarians. Anyone who pays taxes or has to fill out government paperwork develops libertarian impulses almost as a knee-jerk reaction. But terrorism acts as a recruiting station for statists. So it looks to me as though we are headed for a triangular system in which libertarians and statists and terrorists interact with each other in a way that I’m afraid might turn out to be quite stable.
They'll always have Ayn... Posted by Orrin Judd at February 13, 2005 11:29 PM
The used to say that a conservative is a liberal who has been mugged. I guess another definition is a libertarian who has seen 9-11.
Posted by: Robert Schwartz at February 14, 2005 1:49 AMIt's interesting when you travel in the West. You notice that there really doesn't seem to be a need for law enforcement, people seem relatively affluent, the towns are clean, roads in decent repair, etc, and then you start to meet the people. What is striking is what a friend of mine who dropped everything and bought a radio station in Grand Junction, Colorado told me 'The planet is tilted and every loose nut seems to have ended up here.'
There are some very violent, very dangerous wing-nuts out there, and in a pure libertarian environment such people could cause serious problems.
Posted by: Bart at February 14, 2005 7:21 AMoj, pj: would love to see you do a review of Cryptonomicon or one of the Baroque Cycle.
Bart: you must know the only hippie in Grand Junction. It's just another cow town.
Posted by: joe shropshire at February 14, 2005 8:49 AMI concur in directing your critical attention to Neal Stephenson's entire body of writing. Of course, his first two novels were respectively ecoterrorism and cyberpunk nonsense but he seems to have grown up and his themes have progressed from libertarian to conservative by increments.
Cryptonomicon has an especially wonderful defense of traditional monogomous marriage developed from the perspective of a relentlessly secular computer geek. It's also got a great plot and stupendous character development and the later as we all know has never been the greatest strength of SF writers. Athough, I would hesitate to characterize Cryptonomicon as SF at all.
I hsave come to believe that Stephenson is one of the three greatest living American writers. I'll let you know who the other two are as soon as they develop a comparable body of work. The Baroque Cycle is as good as Colleen McCullough's, First Man in Rome series. Higher praise I cannot offer.
Posted by: Ray Clutts at February 14, 2005 10:07 AMRay:
I was especially struck that the real climax of Cryptonomicon (in my view) was not some battle or cunning plan, but a (brief) discussion
between the secular computer geek and a catholic priest about the existance of evil.
Joe,
You must live in a very crabbed world where everyone who doesn't want to be an employee, a hamster on the treadmill or a cog in the machine is somehow a 'hippie.' She's a radio engineer who wanted to work for herself in a pleasant environment. Her comments are not about Grand Junction itself but more directed to what lives in the woods, plains and mountains as you get further away from civilization.
Posted by: Bart at February 14, 2005 1:28 PMMike:
If you've read the Baroque cycle you know that the priest first appeared as an apparently immortal character who may have been the prototype of the wandering Jew of legend. The fact that the wandering Jew later converted to Christianity is one more level of Stephenson's writing that gives me pause as I try and parse his meaning. Biography as history, apparently.
And, in imitation of National Review's recent Groundhog Day cover, I'd put Cryptonomicon up there on my list of the funniest books I've ever read.
Randy Waterhouse's loveless interlude with a humorless and doctrinaire feminist professor is one of the sharpest satire's of PC thought on sex and love that I've ever read. Remember her scholarly critique of his beard? Hilarious.
Posted by: Ray Clutts at February 14, 2005 2:13 PMRay - Gotta disagree with your characterization of his early stuff as nonsense. I haven't read the ecoterrorism one, whichever one that is, but the other stuff is as funny and as lively in style as Cryptonomicon. E.g.,
"A young woman was here, standing before one of the poles with her hands clasped behind her back, which would have given her an endearingly prim appearance if she had not been stark naked and covered with constantly shifting mediatronic tattoos."
- A choice sentence from The Diamond Age.
He also describes a taxi driver's foreign accent as something like "fluid vowels with the occassional sharp consonant, like warm butter infused with shards of glass." (Snow Crash)
Man, Stephenson rocks.
Ray - Gotta disagree with your characterization of his early stuff as nonsense. I haven't read the ecoterrorism one, whichever one that is, but the other stuff is as funny and as lively in style as Cryptonomicon. E.g.,
"A young woman was here, standing before one of the poles with her hands clasped behind her back, which would have given her an endearingly prim appearance if she had not been stark naked and covered with constantly shifting mediatronic tattoos."
- A choice sentence from The Diamond Age.
He also describes a taxi driver's foreign accent as something like "fluid vowels with the occassional sharp consonant, like warm butter infused with shards of glass." (Snow Crash)
Man, Stephenson rocks.
Great Slashdot interview in which his intelligence and wit are evident, as always:
http://slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=04/10/20/1518217
Phasers on stun, Bart, I was just yanking your chain while the morning coffee finished brewing. Grand Junction seemed like a nice sleepy little town, set amid very pretty country ( the Gunnison and Colorado rivers join there, hence the name.) Hope your friend likes it there, and agreed that some of the sodbuster types can be frightening to the uninitiated. Sorta like some commenters on this forum.
Posted by: joe shropshire at February 14, 2005 5:28 PMJoe:
I may be mistaken but I thought that Stephenson's first novel was Zodiac (ecoterror) and his second was Snow Crash. I am a fatally compromised reviewer here since I couldn't stomach enough of Zodiac to finish it.
Snow Crash was adolescent cyberpunk in feel. Both were written.
I sent Orrin an email advocating Diamond Age in regard to the post on Chinese Infanticide preceeding this one. I loved Diamond Age, Cryptonomicon and the entire Baroque Cycle.
Posted by: Ray Clutts at February 14, 2005 7:06 PMRay: I started in with Cryptonomicon, so I don't know either.
Posted by: joe shropshire at February 14, 2005 8:01 PMRead Snowcrash and Diamond Age, started Cryptonomicon and stalled.
Which of his books comprise the Baroque Cycle?
Posted by: Robert Duquette at February 15, 2005 6:23 PMQuicksilver, The Confusion and System of the World. Quicksilver's the best read of the three, I think.
Posted by: joe shropshire at February 15, 2005 10:22 PMThanks Joe.
Posted by: Robert Duquette at February 17, 2005 4:21 PM