February 28, 2005
I DON'T THINK THAT I CAN TAKE IT, 'CAUSE IT TOOK SO LONG TO BAKE IT:
The Times' Turnabout (JAMES TARANTO, February 28, 2005, Best of the Web)
This column last weighed in on the Valerie Plame kerfuffle back in July, when Joe Wilson, having been cast out of the Kerry campaign after a Senate report impeached his credibility, was fulminating that The Wall Street Journal, which was arguing that the special prosecutor's investigation into the "leaking" of his wife's identity as a CIA "operative" should be shut down, was part of a criminal conspiracy.Since then, the prosecutor, Patrick Fitzgerald, has subpoenaed several reporters, two of whom, Judith Miller of the New York Times and Matt Cooper of Time, have refused to testify before a grand jury and are now threatened with jail. Fitzgerald also demanded that Miller and another Times reporter, Philip Shenon, turn over their phone records, but last week a federal judge quashed that request, which prompted a Times editorial Saturday that contained a stunning turnabout:
Meanwhile, an even more basic issue has been raised in recent articles in The Washington Post and elsewhere: the real possibility that the disclosure of Ms. Plame's identity, while an abuse of power, may not have violated any law. Before any reporters are jailed, searching court review is needed to determine whether the facts indeed support a criminal prosecution under existing provisions of the law protecting the identities of covert operatives.
We could have saved them 18 months and a lot of pointless flailing. Posted by Orrin Judd at February 28, 2005 6:01 PM
Oh no! A yellow cake left out in the rain?
Posted by: ghostcat at February 28, 2005 7:06 PMOnly if someone in MacArthur Park outed her.
Posted by: Sandy P at February 28, 2005 10:49 PMHoist by their own petard might also be an appropriate response.
Or maybe what goes around comes around.
Posted by: Robert Schwartz at March 1, 2005 1:34 AMThe Times' editorial department not only still doesn't get blogs, they seem to have a hard time comprehending this entire Internet thing along with the easy access of stored information. You can't go off and contradict your previously held position when it suits your own peronal needs while thinking only people willing to go to a library to get the microfilm or who are willing to pay Nexus charges can compare what you say today to what you said 18 months ago.
Not grasping how easy it is for people to dredge up past news stories, op-eds and editorials makes Gail Collins & Co. come off as both clueless about the world around them and cartoonishly buffonish in changing their own position 180 degrees without shame or explanation.
Posted by: John at March 1, 2005 7:29 AM