January 9, 2005
DR. RICE WILL BE THRILLED TO HEAR THIS
A French call for a new day with U.S.(Roger Cohen, International Herald Tribune, January 10th, 2005)
Michel Barnier, the French foreign minister, is calling for a "new relationship" with the United States and says its first test will be the capacity of President George W. Bush and his European allies to advance a Middle East peace within the next six months."For me, President Bush has a historic responsibility," Barnier said in an interview on Friday. That responsibility, in the post-Arafat Middle East, he said, is to bring Israelis and Palestinians to the negotiating table, ensure a successful Israeli withdrawal from the Gaza Strip and engage talks based on the road map toward peace, "which envisages an Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank." [...]
His commitment to hold regular meetings with American officials and his determination to address differences reinforced and expanded on recent statements from the French president, Jacques Chirac, suggesting that Paris now seeks improved ties.
The discussions, the minister suggested, should aim to draw the United States and France closer on two essential points.
The first, he said, is that the world must be organized not "around a single pillar but several pillars," among them the United States, China, Russia and the European Union.
The EU should be recognized as a steadfast "ally of the Americans," he said, adding: "An alliance does not mean allegiance. It should mean partnership."
He was asked if an alliance meant allegiance at moments of crisis like the Iraq war. "It is never allegiance," Barnier said, his pale blue eyes assuming a steely hue. "An alliance is a partnership based on mutual respect." [...]
When it was put to him that the European Union, which has 25 member nations, was now seen in some conservative circles in Washington as a potential rival whose further integration may not be in the U.S. interest, Barnier retorted that the Union would continue to grow regardless of the Bush administration's views.
"Americans must understand that it is in their interest that Europe get organized and have an autonomy," he said. "It's the price to pay for an effective alliance. The alliance between Europeans and Americans must be balanced."
The second point of discord on which Barnier wants to work with the United States is the fight on terrorism.
"We think that to fight terrorism correctly, you also have to fight the ground in which it grows," he said. That ground, the minister suggested, was poverty and injustice.
"A safer world and a freer world will first be a more just world," Barnier said. "There we have our differences." He did not elaborate on how broader social justice should be achieved.
Andrei Gromyko would be very impressed.
This is just another version of "the Americans should do the heavy lifting at our direction, because we are the smart ones and we know better. Of course, we'll call it a 'partnership', but let there be no doubt that there is a senior partner, the EU (directed by France, Inc.) and a junior partner, the US."
GWB isn't this dumb and hasn't been all along. It doesn't surprise me that the media and the Democrats eat this up, however.
Posted by: Steve White at January 9, 2005 8:29 PMIt would be fun to see the U.S. take this statement and run with it, annoucing that as part of its effort to build a world alliance not "around a single pillar but several pillars," America would support replacing France with India on the U.N. Security Council to give South Asia a greater say in creating the new world order the French are so giddy about creating, since Europe -- with Britain, France and Russia -- is so obviously over-represented on the Security Council.
Posted by: John at January 9, 2005 9:15 PM
SOSO - FOAD
Posted by: Sandy P at January 9, 2005 10:11 PMI didn't get past the first sentence of the second paragraph before I wanted the strangle the French Foreign Minister. Where did I see that Churchill quote about wanting the French die off or something like that?
Posted by: Dusty at January 10, 2005 1:08 AMSS DD
Posted by: Robert Schwartz at January 10, 2005 4:28 AMAll of this recent attempt by the French to cope with 4 more years of the hated cowboy, Bush, is a reflection less of a French desire to cooperate with the US than of a French desire to remain the leader of the EU. None of the new states entering has any interest in offending the US, if anything, they are interested in having close relations with the Americans, for defense and economic reasons. The recent mischief by the Soviets(ahem, Russians) in the Ukraine, Georgia and Moldova is a clear indication that (pace Fukuyama) history has not ended.
The French look at the EU parliament where Italy and Britain have delegations as large as theirs and Germany is about to have a partisan sea change, much to France's detriment, and realize they are going to have to at least appear to be willing to work with the US if they do not wish to be treated like the crazy aunt in the attic. An EU dominated by an alliance between Berlusconi and the former Warsaw Pact states would leave the French in the corner crying into their Bordeaux.
Posted by: Bart at January 10, 2005 6:24 AM