January 4, 2005
AS OPPOSED TO FRANCE'S SENSIBLE HATRED OF AMERICA
America's ridiculous hatred of the French (Antoine Audouard, International Herald Tribune, January 4th, 2005)
As a Parisian who recently moved to New York, I have not personally encountered any American hostility toward me as a French citizen. But I am amazed by the proliferation of French-bashing in the media.If you go on the Internet, you have a vast choice of anti-French Web sites, some selling products (T-shirts emblazoned with insults, for instance), others offering long lists of hilarious "French jokes."
Of course, you could argue that the excesses of bloggers do not paint an accurate picture of American sentiment. You could argue, too, against reading too much into The New York Post's references to President Jacques Chirac of France as a "weasel." It's true that the days of "freedom fries" are behind us and that any recent dent in French exports is more likely the result of a weak dollar than a boycott of French goods. (Back in the days leading up to the war in Iraq, a friend in California called to tell me about a local television commercial for rotisserie-cooked chicken that began: "Don't be a chicken like the French. Eat it.")
But the hysteria of French-bashing has given way to a more insidious form of bias. For example, it was humbling for us French to watch Democratic operatives desperately trying to hide John Kerry's French relatives - who had come to be with him at the Democratic convention - from the news media. And it was rather funny to hear the advice given by some television pundits to Kerry minutes before the first debate: "Don't speak French." (He didn't, and by the way, it made no difference.) And whether in rustic tabloid lingo or in the more refined language of broadsheets, the typical out-of-touch East Coast liberal is more often than not "French-speaking" or "Bordeaux-drinking."
Then there are the jabs delivered by all those late-night comedians. It has become fashionable - even commonplace - in the American media to associate the French with things cowardly, despicable, unfaithful, ungrateful or foul-smelling, in addition to the (more conventional) complaint about Gallic arrogance.
Here in the country of political correctness, where the mainstream media tread on eggshells when talking about race, religion, nation or ethnicity, French-bashing, it would seem, has become politically correct.
M. Audouard, stop whining and be thankful you’re not Canadian.
Posted by Peter Burnet at January 4, 2005 6:27 AMIt's not bashing if it's true.
Posted by: erp at January 4, 2005 8:58 AMBack in the mid 1980s, when Paramount and Gene Roddenberry decided to revive the Star Trek franchise with a new generation of characters, they tried to create a new race of aliens, the Ferengi, who would serve as the new villians to be hated by cast and viewers. Unfortunately, the Ferengi came over as more a group of petty, self-centered and inept hot-heads who were more a source of ridicule than they ever were of hatred. So the Romulans had to be dragged out of monthballs to serve as the designated enemy-of-the-week, while the Ferengi became a source of humor for the writers whenever they were trotted out.
For all intents and purposes, that pretty much describes the French in the eyes of most Americans. They're not a source of hatred per se, but their transparently self-centered and petty attitudes are a prime target for ridicule and disdain. If the French thought about it for any length of time, the fact that they're not even worthy of villany status, but are seen more as the comedy relief of world nations, would probably make them fume about their own growing irrelevance even more than they do right now.
Posted by: John at January 4, 2005 9:24 AMnot "politically correct" -- "correct" simply.
Posted by: pj at January 4, 2005 10:27 AMThe Ferengi had to be transformed into comic relief because they were an attempt by Roddenberry to trade in anti-semitic stereotypes. Short, greedy, big-nosed villains went a little too close to the bone for many Hollywood money people.
This chameau Ardouard should know that it was the French who started it. They went down the path of knee-jerk anti-Americanism, who whine endlessly about American 'hyperpower', who are trying to create a 'European counterweight' run from the Elysee Palace, who undermine us in the UN and support terrorists all over the world.
If the average American had any say, we would have bombed Paris a long time ago, certainly after the diversion during the bombing of Libya.
Posted by: Bart at January 4, 2005 10:34 AMAmericans have become dismissive of the French. Hatred is an inappropriate reaction to silly people. I think that it bothers them more as well. They'd rather we took them seriously.
Posted by: Tom C., Stamford,Ct. at January 4, 2005 11:23 AMAussie wine is better and cheaper too.
Posted by: Robert Schwartz at January 5, 2005 2:33 AMWe all know in France that behind French bashing ther are frustration, ignorance and very unhappy people unable to talk or give good arguments about a country they dont know. Lies and slanders are on the USA side; thought and arguments on French side. Nothing n ew under the sun. Bye
Frédéric Masse
