October 6, 2004
ROUNDHEAD REDUX:
Turkey's march West (Yigal Schleifer, 10/07/04, The Christian Science Monitor)
As a devout Muslim, Celal Hasnalcaci believes women should cover their hair and dress modestly, as the Koran teaches. As the general director of Keep Out, a growing company that exports denim clothing from this city in the Turkish heartland to Europe, he makes jeans that hug the hips and expose more than a bit of midriff, as today's fashion dictates.Mr. Hasnalcaci, a soft-spoken man with a graying mustache, sees no contradiction in that. He is both a Muslim and a businessman, he says. He also sees no contradiction in Muslim Turkey's bid to join the European Union.
"Our religion is Islam, but it doesn't say not to join with others. It says take your religion everywhere and show its goodness. If you don't show yourself, they won't understand you," he says.
"If we want to be modern and be technical and improve, we have to be together with the Europeans," he adds.
Hasnalcaci is part of a fast-rising entrepreneurial class known as the Anatolian Tigers.
Over the past decade, these Islamic-minded business owners from Turkey's conservative Anatolia region have emerged as a counterweight to the country's established secular elite.
As Turkey moves ever closer to its long-held goal of joining the EU, people like Hasnalcaci have become an important - and perhaps surprising - force behind the country's westward push.
They're embracing the old elite's European dream for Turkey, yet steadfastly holding on to their Muslim identity and conservative lifestyle.
It is a synthesis, observers here say, that could influence which Turkey will eventually greet Europe - and which aspects of Europe Turkey will eventually accept.
"This is the new face of Turkey. Ten years ago, some of this Islamic bourgeoisie was hesitant about joining the EU, but the hearts and minds have changed," says Nilufer Narli, a sociologist at Istanbul's Kadir Has University.
"They are for progress and modernization but with a big difference - they want to conserve their traditional life in the family and with their acquaintances," she adds. "They really want to adopt European norms, but there are some areas, like gender relations, where it won't be easy for them to do that."
Upon such a foundation--not unlike the Protestant middle class of 17th Century Britain--might a great Islam be built, one that will rapidly surpass the dying secular Europe and become a genuine counterpart to America. Posted by Orrin Judd at October 6, 2004 7:50 PM
>Upon such a foundation--not unlike the
>Protestant middle class of 17th Century Britain-
>-might a great Islam be built, one that will
>rapidly surpass the dying secular Europe and
>become a genuine counterpart to America.
If it's allowed to live and grow long enough.
Problem is, Islam has a tendency to respond to future shock via "Holy Book Tunnel Vision" (withdrawal into a festering Purity), and the most tunnel-visioned and "pure" are usually the nastiest and most destructive.
Even if Islam goes through its reformation and emerges as described above, the Holy Book Tunnel Vision of the Wahabi/Salafi/Taliban (with its 72 virgins for all eternity for Jihadis) will always be there, waiting in the literal text of the Holy Book for the disaffected and disenfranchised and young/rebellious.
Posted by: Ken at October 6, 2004 8:05 PMKen:
Yes, that's been vital to our survival too: the great awakenings, abolition, prohibition, anti-abortion, etc. All have revitalized and remoralized imperilled society.
Posted by: oj at October 6, 2004 8:12 PMI was hung over that day, oj. Remind me, which side were the roundheads on? And don't say "the other side from the cavaliers." Thanks.
Posted by: joe shropshire at October 6, 2004 8:26 PMjoe:
The Puritan pro-Parliamentarians in the English Civil War.
Posted by: oj at October 6, 2004 9:38 PMBooyah.
Posted by: joe shropshire at October 6, 2004 10:36 PMAmerican Prohibition was a failure.
The rate of alcohol consumption had been decreasing since WW I, in both America and England. During Prohibition, the rate continued to fall in England, but although the consumption of beer and wine in the US fell sharply, the rate of liquor consumption skyrocketed.
Some "remoralization".
Posted by: Michael Herdegen at October 6, 2004 11:41 PMMichael:
All of the social pathologies associated with alcoholism fell during Prohibition and its legacy lives on in raised drinking ages, harsh drunk driving laws, the social unacceptability of drunkeness, the war on drugs, etc.
Posted by: oj at October 6, 2004 11:47 PMYour Islam fetish is madness. Islam is a religion of death.
Posted by: AML at October 7, 2004 12:38 AMThen why are there a billion Muslims?
Posted by: oj at October 7, 2004 12:44 AMThere are a billion Muslims because there's no feminine access to birth control in most Muslim societies.
Wait until every Muslimette can get her hands on some birth control pills or the patch, and then we'll see if future Muslim populations continue to grow.
