October 27, 2004

MY LAWYER SAYS IT ALL HANGS ON WHAT YOU MEAN BY KILL

Elmasry remarks probed as hate crime (Marina Jiménez, Globe and Mail, October 27th, 2004)

Police are investigating whether comments by the president of the Canadian Islamic Congress constitute a hate crime.

Mohamed Elmasry said that all Israelis over 18 are fair targets for suicide bombers. He later recanted this view, saying he was trying to express a widely held Palestinian position, not his own.

His remarks and apology continue to cause outrage among Jewish and Muslim groups, which are calling for his resignation. The comments have sparked a probe by Halton Regional Police and by the University of Waterloo, where Mr. Elmasry is a professor of computer engineering.[...]

Mr. Elmasry did not return calls, but the CIC issued a statement on the weekend saying the group's president was trying to convey a widely held Palestinian view and regrets that his comments were misunderstood and caused offence.

But the Canadian Jewish Congress said a review of the television tape reveals it was his "personal, passionately held view" that all Israeli civilians over 18 are legitimate targets for suicide bombers.

The Canadian Muslim Congress and the Canadian-Arab Federation also reject the notion that Mr. Elmasry speaks for Palestinians, saying they do not uniformly endorse this position.

Yes, for example there is that little wet wimp, Abdul, who only wants to murder the men, but we’re working on him. In the meantime, we look forward to Mr. Elmasry’s months’ long trial, which we are confident will thoroughly exhaust the public and drown any civilized, visceral outrage in a cleverly deconstructed indictment of history.

Posted by Peter Burnet at October 27, 2004 7:17 AM
Comments

"they do not uniformly endorse his view"

Well, I guess they don't condemn it, either.

Posted by: jim hamlen at October 27, 2004 11:21 AM

Hoist by their own petard. Liberal Jews in Canada cannot decide whether to defecate or wind their watches.

Posted by: Robert Schwartz at October 27, 2004 10:42 PM

It does seem that Muslims the world around say these things among themselves, including whatever passes for opinion/religious leaders, doesn't it?

Are they trying to tell us something?

Posted by: Harry Eagar at October 28, 2004 12:20 AM
« THE OTHER DAY UPON THE STAIR, I MET A MAN WHO WASN’T THERE | Main | ETHNICALLY VS. RELIGIOUSLY: »