October 17, 2004
JENNY HAS TWO MOMMIES. NO, REALLY.
Babies with three parents ahead (Antony Barnett and Robin McKie, The Observer, October 17, 2004)
Scientists are seeking permission to carry out experiments that would result in children being born with three biological parents. UK medical authorities say they will almost certainly approve the application in the next few weeks.The aim of the technique is to prevent mothers passing on degenerative genetic diseases to their children. But campaigners say it could lead to significant increases in elderly women having children. They also claim it represents an unacceptable step towards the creation of designer babies.
'By creating a child with three genetic parents, these scientists are taking the first step towards genetic engineering of human beings. That is not a direction in which we should be going,' said Dr David King, director of Human Genetics Alert.
The technology - which is being developed by a team at Newcastle University - will involve the implanting of the nucleus of an embryo from an affected mother into an egg taken from a donor that has been stripped of its nucleus.
Human eggs carry small spherical or rod-like bodies called mitochondria, which supply energy for the growing foetus. These have their own genes, inherited separately from the child's main chromosomal genes.
Crucially, some mitochondrial DNA is defective and can pass on one of around 50 degenerative diseases. It is thought more than 1,000 children in Britain suffer from diseases caused by defective mitochondria, some ending up with chronic brain disease.
Neurologist Professor Doug Turnbull and embryologist Dr Mary Herbert believe that by implanting the nucleus of an embryo of a mother with defective mitochondria into the egg of a woman with healthy mitochondria, the resultant foetus will be free of the destructive genetic diseases.
A society that surrenders its ethical compass to an unrestrained compulsion to make scientific and medical “advances” will soon find itself in dark and chilling places.
Posted by Peter Burnet at October 17, 2004 9:09 AMThese are the same people who are worried about Frankenfoods?
Posted by: Robert Duquette at October 17, 2004 1:17 PMI find the page linked to by Peter Burnet -- which claims there is hardly any difference between abortion doctor Barney Slepian and Nazi doctor J. Mengele -- highly unpersuasive.
Posted by: Eugene S. at October 17, 2004 3:14 PMCuriously, the Father of Our Country believed the same thing, and killed on the belief, though only dogs.
Posted by: Harry Eagar at October 17, 2004 4:58 PM