September 9, 2004
HEY, YOU CAN'T DISRUPT MY DISRUPTION:
The Right's Stuff: A Texas-based band of conservative warriors tackles the left on its own turf--the street (ROBERT WILONSKY, 9/09/04, Dallas Observer)
On a Friday afternoon in late August they've come to this street corner to raise their signs and voices to protest the venal forces that would bring down the United States. They brandish placards and peace signs, and passing motorists wave back in agreement, offer their own gestures consisting of a single middle finger or ignore them. The demonstrators are mostly white men, ranging in age from 16 to mid-40s, and among their signs is one that reads, in part, "War never solved anything!"For months this protest has been taking place in front of the Dallas offices of a company many Americans believe to be evil. With their signs and slogans the protesters stand on the front lawn of the corporation once run by Vice President Dick Cheney, Houston-based Halliburton Co., damned by Democrats for receiving billions in no-bid contracts for reconstructing Iraq.
But look closely at the signs. The one that says, "War never solved anything"? It says something just above that: "Except for ending slavery, fascism, Nazism & Communism..." And wait, what about those other signs they're holding? There's one with Osama bin Laden dressed as Uncle Sam. It reads, "Uncle Osama wants you to vote for John Kerry." There's another one with bin Laden on it: "Vote Kerry 2004 so I can kill your family." One says, "9/11 was just freedom of speech!" And another placard pleads, "Help! I'm surrounded by America-hating idiots!" And... waitaminute. That guy over there's wearing a T-shirt that reads--can this be right?--"I Halliburton."
What the hell?
Welcome to another Friday afternoon in the ongoing Operation Halliburton Defense Force being carried out by members of the Dallas chapter of a group of right-wingers called Protest Warrior. Their mission is to protest the protesters from the Dallas Peace Center who have been here since April to demonstrate against Halliburton. The Warriors' ideology is a bit more labyrinthine, a smorgasbord of conservative and libertarian ideas sprinkled with activism more commonly associated with lefties. Their motto is crystal-clear: "Fighting the left...doing it right." [...]
"Right to left, left to right, when you intrude upon someone else's event you are asking for a confrontation, not a debate," says Columbia journalism professor Todd Gitlin, who, as former president of Students for a Democratic Society, organized the first Vietnam War protest in March 1965. "When you enter into an emotionally charged arena in a pugnacious spirit you get a fight, not a debate. They will be martyrs and heroes. That sounds like pure political combat. The slogan 'Protest Warrior' is an interesting one. Is it that they are warriors or protesters?...It's another gimmick for belligerent right-wingers."
Fascists! When the Left protests someone else's event they become the event and are therefore inviolable! Posted by Orrin Judd at September 9, 2004 11:32 AM
Gitlin's statement is easily understood. The left is on the side of HISTORY. The rest are despicable atavists preventing the arrival of utopia. Bad atavists, naughty atavists.
Posted by: luciferous at September 9, 2004 11:41 AMProtest Warrior is a great new vehicle for the foot soldiers of the Right. I think they scare the Left almost as much as that internet thingy.
Posted by: Jim Gooding at September 9, 2004 12:32 PMI think Gitlin's statement reflects the totalitarian ideals for which he stands. In his Utopia, dissent would not be brooked. Good for PW for holding up a mirror to the left's neoStalinism.
Posted by: Melissa at September 9, 2004 12:49 PMDear Prof. Gitlin:
Suck it up, you whiny, bitter, over-age brat.
Sincerely,
Mikey
Dear Prof. Gitlin:
who said that the PW's wanted to 'enter into an emotionally charged arena in a pugnacious spirit'?
I say they're just exercising their right of dissent which has kept this country strong for over 200 years!
MMMMBWAAAH!
scares you , doesn't it?
To bad, Prof.Gitlin, they aren't nice people who restrict themselves to blowing up campus libraries and rioting like the SDS. They have the temerity to carry picket signs. OH! THE HORROR! THE HORROR!!!
Posted by: Bart at September 9, 2004 1:36 PMIn one of his books, David Horowitz tells a funny story about Gitlin from back when they were allies in the late '60s (IIRC). David needed a break from all the politics, and was planning a scuba-diving vacation in Mexico. Gitlin, in everything-is-politics mode, thought for a bit and said: "Good. The revolution will need frogmen."
Posted by: PapayaSF at September 9, 2004 3:13 PMOne more sign that The Left(tm) is now The Establishment(tm).
Posted by: Chris B at September 9, 2004 4:40 PMI attended one of PW's events last year during a "peace rally" in D.C. The police had to cordon us off so we wouldn't be physically attacked by the "pacifists."
I came away with a poster reading: "France: You shut the hell up. We'll protect civilization."
Posted by: Matt Murphy at September 9, 2004 6:54 PM