July 23, 2004
A SPOONFUL OF SUGAR HELPS THE ELEPHANT GO DOWN:
President Emphasizes Minority Entrepreneurship at Urban League (Remarks by the President to the 2004 National Urban League Conference, 7/23/04, Detroit Marriot Renaissance Hotel)
Ours is a solid record of accomplishment. And that's why I've come to talk about compassionate conservatism and what I envision for the future. I'm here for another reason. I'm here to ask for your vote. (Applause.)No, I know, I know, I know. The Republican party has got a lot of work to do. I understand that. (Laughter and applause.) You didn't need to nod your head that hard, Jesse. (Laughter.)
Do you remember a guy named Charlie Gaines? Somebody gave me a quote he said, which I think kind of describes the environment we're in today. I think he's a friend of Jesse's. He said, "Blacks are gagging on the donkey but not yet ready to swallow the elephant." (Laughter and applause.)
Now that was said a while ago. (Laughter.) I believe you've got to earn the vote and seek it. I think you've got to go to people and say, this is my heart, this is what I believe, and I'd like your help. And as I do, I'm going to ask African American voters to consider some questions.
Does the Democrat party take African American voters for granted? (Applause.) It's a fair question. I know plenty of politicians assume they have your vote. But do they earn it and do they deserve it? (Applause.) Is it a good thing for the African American community to be represented mainly by one political party? That's a legitimate question. (Applause.) How is it possible to gain political leverage if the party is never forced to compete? (Applause.) Have the traditional solutions of the Democrat party truly served the African American community?
That's what I hope people ask when they go to the community centers and places, as we all should do our duty and vote. People need to be asking these very serious questions.
Does blocking the faith-based initiative help neighborhoods where the only social service provider could be a church? Does the status quo in education really, really help the children of this country? (Applause.)
Does class warfare -- has class warfare or higher taxes ever created decent jobs in the inner city? Are you satisfied with the same answers on crime, excuses for drugs and blindness to the problem of the family? (Applause.)
Those are legitimate questions that I hope people ask as this election approaches. I'd like to hear those questions debated on talk radio, I'd like it debated in community centers, in the coffee shops. It's worthy of this country for this debate to go forward and these questions to be asked and answered.
I'm here to say that there is an alternative this year. There is an alternative that has had a record that is easy to see. If you dream of starting a small business and building a nest egg and passing something of value to your children, take a look at my agenda. If you believe schools should meet high standards instead of making excuses, take a look at my agenda. If you believe the institutions of marriage and family are worth defending and need defending today, take a look at my agenda. (Applause.)
If you believe in building a culture of life in America, take a look at my agenda. If you believe in a tireless fight against crime and drugs, take a look at this agenda. If you believe that our men and women in uniform should be respected and supported 100 percent of the time, take a look at my agenda. (Applause.)
If you're struggling to get into the middle class and you feel like you're paying plenty of taxes, take a look at my agenda. (Applause.)
If you're a small business owner who is trying to expand your job base and are worried about excessive lawsuits, increasing taxes and over-regulation, take a look at this agenda. (Applause.)
And finally, if you believe in the power of faith and compassion to defeat violence and despair and hopelessness, I hope you take a look at where I stand. (Applause.)
You see, I believe in my heart that the Republican party, the party of Lincoln and Frederick Douglass, is not complete without the perspective and support and contribution of African Americans. (Applause.)
And I believe in my heart that the policies and actions of this administration, policies that empower individuals and help communities, that lift up free enterprise and respect and honor the family, those policies are good for the nation as a whole. That's what I believe. And I'm here to thank you for giving me a chance to come and express those beliefs.
I'm proud to be with an organization that does so good, so much good for the American people. I'm honored that your Chairman would extend an invitation to me. Thanks for coming, and may God bless you and may God continue to bless the country.
Posted by Orrin Judd at July 23, 2004 4:16 PM
If you believe the institutions of marriage and family are worth defending and need defending today, take a look at my agenda. (Applause.) If you believe in building a culture of life in America, take a look at my agenda. If you believe in a tireless fight against crime and drugs, take a look at this agenda. If you believe that our men and women in uniform should be respected and supported 100 percent of the time, take a look at my agenda. (Applause.)
I guess he hasn't got the message that he's got to run away from his far right social agenda.
Posted by: David Cohen at July 23, 2004 4:43 PMGW is the only hope for urban black kids. The greedy slave traders Jesse Jackson et al. are waiting for them to graduate high school illiterate and vote as they tell them.
There is zero political gain for GW to think even one thought about black America, black "leaders" will no doubt reward this fine speech by labeling him a Nazi in tomorrow's press.
Posted by: Jim Gooding at July 23, 2004 4:46 PMI agree with instapundit's comment on this speech in that it probably won't help him much in November but is the right thing to say. I remain mildy optimistic that Bush will do better among African-American voters since the NAACP can't paint him as the man from the Byrd ads of the 2000 campaign.
Posted by: AWW at July 23, 2004 4:51 PMOn a related note, WDET (Detroit's National People's Radio outlet) gave extensive coverage to this, emphasizing how the President "... snubbed ..." the NAACP.
Without once mentioning why. No quote from the White House on the issue. No quotes from the NAACP leadership. Their story left the President's decision absolutely devoid of context.
Disgusting.
Posted by: Jeff Guinn at July 23, 2004 7:13 PMHopefully, this subject will be revisited during the presidential debates by Bush, which will then require more than a laundry list of government programs in response by Kerry.
Posted by: John at July 23, 2004 7:25 PMMaking the speech was both smart and gutsy, even if Bush still doesn't rise above 10% in black votes. He played offense, instead of defense. And it was well written.
And of course, it's a snub of the NAACP. The NAACP has for generations told everyone that it is the nation's foremost black, er, civil rights organization. Thus, when a president speaks before any other black organization, without first going hat in hand to the NAACP, it is a snub.
And it is a smart use of the presidential bully pulpit that no GOP president of my recollection has engaged in, regarding race relations. Black groups have for almost 40 years assumed that they will dictate racial "dialogue" to white presidents, with presidents, especially GOP presidents, having to forego their own right to formulate policy and morally lead the nation.
And the Urban League official who invited the President did a very smart thing, too. He showed that the Urban League truly is tolerant and open to dialogue, as opposed to just patting itself on the back, for virtues it lacks, at the same time that it symbolically punched the NAACP in the eye, in challenging its role as the nation's foremost black political organization.
My experience reading articles and speeches by UL officials is that they are generally politically correct, but have sometimes shown latent pragmatic tendencies.
Posted by: Nicholas Stix at July 23, 2004 7:55 PMGreat speech.
Posted by: genecis at July 23, 2004 8:12 PMAnd it wasn't a "what I can do for you" type of speech, but rather a "what you can do for yourselves" speech. This is just a hunch on my part, but I think the old Booker T. Washington "Pull yourself by your bootstraps" message could still have resonance with people tired of the politicians' promise of goodies that never quite get to where they're supposed to go.
Posted by: John Barrett Jr. at July 23, 2004 8:48 PMAWW--
"...since the NAACP can't paint him as the man from the Byrd ads of the 2000 campaign."
Why can't they?
Posted by: jsmith at July 23, 2004 11:20 PMI took the President's opening remark to be a pretty vicious slam at the NAACP: You know, Marc, you're right, the National Urban League is a vital and important part of the American scene. And I think the reason why is, not only is the mission important, but the people involved in the Urban League are dignified, decent American citizens.
Posted by: David Cohen at July 23, 2004 11:26 PMThey "get" vouchers - they want vouchers and know who gave it to them.
Posted by: Sandy P at July 23, 2004 11:44 PM