May 19, 2004

THE CLINTON LEGACY:

Kosovo's religious tables turned: Where is the outcry over anti-Serb, anti-Christian attacks? (Lawrence A. Uzzell, 5/20/04, CS Monitor)

Six years ago the US launched a noble experiment, becoming the first nation to proclaim international religious freedom as a goal of its foreign policy. Unfortunately, that experiment has been poisoned by interest-group politics. Usually the US speaks up only for persecuted religious denominations that have large memberships in America or good connections in Washington. Others are mostly ignored - as is the case with Kosovo now.

The ethnic Albanian Muslims who dominate that strife-torn Balkan province have been pursuing what a NATO commander recently called "orchestrated and well-planned ethnic cleansing" against minority Christian Serbs. In mid-March, Kosovo Albanian mobs destroyed 30 churches in two days. (The mobs were inflamed by reckless reports in local media, presenting as fact a rumor that Serb teens had drowned three Albanian boys; NATO officials now say they believe the drowning was accidental.) Some of these churches had been places of Christian worship since the 14th century, jewels of medieval architecture treasured by art historians worldwide. Today they're ashen ruins. Thousands of their former parishioners are now refugees; some are dead.

Imagine the outcry if these had been Baptist or Roman Catholic churches, or synagogues. But Eastern Orthodox Christians seem to have almost no sympathizers in the US except among fellow Orthodox - and among the few human rights advocates who pursue freedom not just for their own co-religionists, but for everyone. Especially friendless are the Serbian Orthodox...


All actions by a democracy are self-justifying--we're never going to admit we intervened in favor of the wrong side.

Posted by Orrin Judd at May 19, 2004 11:11 PM
Comments

Who's this "we" you speak of? The media didn't write about this because it doesn't fit into their "let's let the wonderful UN/NATO/not-US run everything" storyline, NOT because it makes the US look bad. The total suppression of the murder of multiple Americans by a fellow UN policeman is among the most disgraceful examples of the phenomenon.

Posted by: brian at May 19, 2004 11:49 PM

We the People

Posted by: oj at May 19, 2004 11:53 PM

If We the People knew about these things, We would be ticked. We're not, but not because We refuse to admit mistakes, but because We don't know these facts.

Posted by: brian at May 20, 2004 12:07 AM

Brian is correct about the importance of the "murder" by Muslims in Kosovo. One would have thought that would have been a big story under any circumstances. Were not the Muslims Jordanians (honestly, I could be wrong about that, so correct me if I am)? Yet mere weeks later Bush involves himself in a giant suckup to the King of Jordan.

OJ if you are trying change the behavior of a people, you use whatever weapons are available, sometimes guns, sometimes PR. Bush can make it a story or not bother. The UN needs to be on the defensive, not just on your blog, but around the world. Muslims need to be held to a standard of behavior in front of all of the world. Continually to shrug this off, while bloviating about fraternity pranks, will not move Muslims to any fundamental change.

Posted by: h-man at May 20, 2004 3:44 AM

h:

Yes, the point being that we, the UN, NATO, etc. endorsed the wrong side in the Balkans. But having done se we won't ever acknowledge it. Democracies don't make mistakes.

Posted by: oj at May 20, 2004 7:28 AM

It is difficult to sympathize with the moral equivalent of the SS (and, for the Serbs, that was their choice in 1940-41 as well).

Posted by: jim hamlen at May 20, 2004 12:01 PM

But OJ, isn't Islam the hope against secularized Europeans?

Posted by: Chris Durnell at May 20, 2004 12:04 PM

Chris:

Yes. No one will long mourn the passing of the Christian Serbs.

Posted by: oj at May 20, 2004 12:20 PM

Jim:

If you think the Serbs were bad, check out the Croats. There are no good guys or bad guys in the Balkans. It's like Hatfields and McCoys.

Posted by: Peter B at May 20, 2004 1:12 PM

Peter:

It is probably worse, but when the Serbs tried to expand against the Croats in 91-92, they were rebuffed. So they went south. Probably the best answer would be to import about 50 million Chinese and give them manifest destiny in the old Yugoslavia.

Posted by: jim hamlen at May 20, 2004 1:26 PM

There was no right side, we sided with the group that was getting slaughtered. We stopped the wholesale violence, but no doubt the 'retail' violence will continue on for some time.

Posted by: Robert Duquette at May 20, 2004 2:20 PM

The slaughterers can be the right side, as when we're the ones slaughtering

Posted by: oj at May 20, 2004 2:28 PM

This is all too horibly complicated to explain.

Everbody is wrong. The worst book is the most highly praised -- Rebecca West "Black Falcon Grey Lamb,"

For more than a century Serb nationalists have claimed the right to occupy and rule Kosovo on the grounds that they lost a battle there 600 years ago. (try repeating that out loud without laughing). Had they claimed the right of a minority to live in peace and practice their religion they might have garnered sympathy.

The Albanians are behaving like members of their religion, no not muslim, pagans avenging a blood feud. All they had to do was wait until the multi national peace keeping effort was drawn down. Gives you a lot of confidence in Kerry's ideas doesn't it?

The Croats who are not part of this play are nto nice.

Bloody mess.

Posted by: Robert Schwartz at May 21, 2004 12:16 AM

Kagan wrote about this in Balkan Journey. Everybody is an irredentist in the Balkans, dreaming of some long ago age when they were on top and controlled the region. They all have horrific slaughter tales and they all feel it just happened yesterday and their ancestors are crying out for vengeance. You can admire them culturally, but as nations they are all hopeless.

Any foreign policy activity in that region should be based upon drawing firm lines in the sand and threatening those who cross them. Anyone who tries to goes in from a right and wrong or human rights perspective will end up with a migraine and a lot of dead people.

Posted by: Peter B at May 21, 2004 4:25 AM

They'r all animals. Let them kill each other off, I don't care.

Posted by: Amos at May 21, 2004 5:51 AM

It wasn't Kagan it was Robert Kaplan who swallowed Rebeca West hook line and stinker. Balkan Ghosts : A Journey Through History by Robert D. Kaplan. A far better book is: Kosovo : A Short History by Noel Malcolm.

It should be noted that Serb nationalism, like all balkan nationalisms was a creation of 19th century Europeans. In the Serbian case, Russians seeking a wedge between the the Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman-Turkish Empires manufactured Serb nationalism out of Pan-slavism, Orthodox Brotherhood, and a couple of old folk songs.

It is this poisonous brew that is the basis of the legend of age old hatreds.

Posted by: Robert Schwartz at May 21, 2004 6:38 PM
« BEST, BUT BUNS UP: | Main | 60-40 FILES: »