May 11, 2004

IN CASE YOU WONDERED WHY HOWARD DEAN WAS PRO-GUN:

How to Catch Fish in Vermont: No Bait, No Tackle, Just Bullets (PAM BELLUCK, 5/11/04, NY Times)

The hunter's prey darted into the shadows, just out of reach of Henry Demar's gun.

"Come on, stand up and be counted," Mr. Demar whispered excitedly. "There was a ripple that came out of the weeds. There's something out there."

Dressed in camouflage, gripping his .357 Magnum, Mr. Demar was primed to shoot. But this time, no such luck. With a flick of its tail, his quarry — a slick silvery fish — was gone.

Fish shooting is a sport in Vermont, and every spring, hunters break out their artillery — high-caliber pistols, shotguns, even AK-47's — and head to the marshes to exercise their right to bear arms against fish.

It is a controversial pastime, and Vermont's fish and wildlife regulators have repeatedly tried to ban it. They call it unsportsmanlike and dangerous, warning that a bullet striking water can ricochet across the water like a skipping stone.

But fish shooting has survived, a cherished tradition for some Vermont families and a novelty to some teenagers and twenty-somethings. Fixated fish hunters climb into trees overhanging the water (some even build "fish blinds" to sit in), sail in small skiffs or perch on the banks of marshes that lace Lake Champlain, on Vermont's northwest border.

"They call us crazy, I guess, to go sit in a tree and wait for fish to come out," said Dean Paquette, 66, as he struggled to describe the fish-shooting rush. "It's something that once you've done it . . ."

Mr. Paquette, a retired locomotive engineer, has passed fish shooting on to his children and grandchildren, including his daughter, Nicki, a nurse.

"You have to be a good shot," said Ms. Paquette, 31, who started shooting at age 6. "It's a challenge. I think that's why people do it."

Her 87-year-old great-uncle, Earl Picard, is so enthusiastic that, against the better judgment of his relatives, he frequently drives 75 miles from his home in Newport to Lake Champlain. Mr. Picard still climbs trees, although "most of the trees that I used to climb in are gone," he said. "You can sit up there in the sun and the birds will come and perch on your hat and look you in the eye."


Bo Jackson used to take his Kansas City Royals teammates fishing with longbows.

Posted by Orrin Judd at May 11, 2004 10:01 AM
Comments

My uncle used to have an old crank telephone he used for "fishing" in Oklahoma creeks and ponds. Highly illegal, but effective. :)

Posted by: kevin whited at May 11, 2004 10:18 AM

I had an old scoutmaster in Vermont who told me of trying everything he could think of to land a large brook trout which hung out for days in a pool along the front of his house. He finally resorted to a 30-30, which did the trick.

It is, of course, legal to take carp and pike with spears and arrows as well as firearms, but shooting trout out of streams is not approved of by the authorities.

Great photo heading the orininal article on the Times site.

Posted by: Jason Johnson at May 11, 2004 1:43 PM

"there are now more fat people in the world than hungry people."

Paul Ehrlich, call your office, stat!

Posted by: Jeff Guinn at May 11, 2004 9:36 PM
« TERRORISM? YOU THINK THE MOST IMPORTANT ISSUE IS TERRORISM? | Main | NOW THEY PLAY SOCCER: »