March 2, 2004

WELL, I THINK I'VE DONE ENOUGH DAMAGE...:

Lobbing a Grenade at Women's Magazines (DAVID CARR, 3/02/04, NY Times)

When Myrna Blyth, the former editor of Ladies' Home Journal and the author of a new book excoriating women's magazines, walks through Michael's restaurant in Midtown Manhattan, all eyes in that gathering spot for the media elite seem to follow her. She appears not to notice, but when she takes a seat, she sits with her back against a wall.

Not to worry. In the air-kissing environs of Michael's and the magazine world, no one would be so bold as to confront Ms. Blyth about her new book, Spin Sisters: How the Women of the Media Sell Unhappiness and Liberalism to the Women of America. But after her decision to throw a grenade over her shoulder upon leaving an industry she was very much a part of for more than three decades, many in her former cohort see her as traitorous and self-interested.

In the book Ms. Blyth indicts a whole category of magazines as politically tendentious and editorially alarmist. "Deep down, most of our Spin Sisters are just good old-fashioned left-wingers, wired for a liberal response to every issue," she writes. Ms. Blyth suggests that this reflexively liberal bent stems from the conceit that women are victims. "Do we spend our days worrying whether antiperspirants cause breast cancer or wondering if a long airline ride will cause a fatal blood clot?" she writes. "Or are we just observing today's favorite media technique to paint women's lives to women audiences as a picture of accumulated woes?" [...]

Ms. Blyth, 64, was editor of Ladies' Home Journal for more than two decades, arriving in 1981 from Family Circle to turn around a foundering magazine. In 1998 she helped conceive More, a magazine for women over 40, one of the most successful new magazines in recent years. She retired last July from the Meredith Corporation, which also publishes Better Homes and Gardens and other women's magazines.

Ms. Blyth said she had written "Spin Sisters" both as a corrective and a penance. "I was a Spin Sister," she said during a recent lunch. "I used the female fear factor to sell magazines."


You'd like to think that as the baby boom generation retires they'll take with them the Leftist orthodoxy that even most of them by now realize has done nothing but ruin their own lives and the previously healthy institutions they've run into the ground over the last forty years.

Posted by Orrin Judd at March 2, 2004 7:56 AM
Comments

Read 'Jane' magazine.
It's Gen-X leftism, but funny, sarcastic, post-ironic and informative.

Posted by: Michael Herdegen at March 2, 2004 10:29 AM

Don't count on it, Orrin.

I have three sisters, all with college degrees and all infected. As an example they all fell for the contaminated salmon story, which was designed to scare the scientifically illiterate, hook line and sinker. (pun intended)

Posted by: Jason Johnson at March 2, 2004 11:17 AM

I used to work in the ad side of magazines and I can tell you that there would be no way to fill 12 issues without recycling old material and making mountains out of molehills. There are so many women's magazines out there and, while they're mostly ads, they ran out of worthwhile information for women a long time ago.

Add to that the editorial copy created just to promote the biggest money advertisers and you've got your hands on one big waste of a reader's time.

Posted by: NKR at March 2, 2004 11:24 AM

I can't wait until the feminists get to retirement age, and realize that all they have in the waning years is...nothing. No lifetime partner/husband, no family, no children. Just the sterile bleakness of 4 walls and a cat.

Posted by: ray at March 2, 2004 8:17 PM

Then they will worry over articles like "Is your cat emitting deadly radon gas", or "Why four walls: Patriarchy's architectural legacy of opression."

Posted by: Robert Duquette at March 2, 2004 10:24 PM

Check out an excellent article by Anna Blundy in the Guradian on February 20:
"Thou shalt obey Fun?"
http://shopping.guardian.co.uk/books/story/0,1587,1155035,00.html

Posted by: Rockette Mcknight at March 10, 2004 8:02 AM

url correction

Posted by: Thou Shalt Obey Fun at March 10, 2004 8:05 AM
« ENEMIES OF CIVILIZATION: | Main | RED EGGS AND HAM (via The Mother Judd): »