December 17, 2003
BASHING AMERICA INSTEAD OF HELPING IRAN:
Spare a thought for us -- first: Ebadi's wasted opportunity? (Ardavan Bahrami, December 15, 2003, The Iranian)
A few days ago I received an email from a friend whom I have never met in person but have been chatting and exchanging views with on Iranian current affairs. The email contained a note from an Iranian gentleman/lady who had commented on Shirin Ebadi's Nobel Peace prize speech.The note was most refreshing and above all extremely courageous. Consequently, my journalistic conscience told me that such a fresh viewpoint should not be ignored. As I do not know this person nor does my friend, I have taken the liberty to use the note and expand it further, hoping many others could enjoy the comments.
To make it easier I shall call this person Hope! Hope's note starts by saying,
"Shirin Ebadi's Nobel Peace Prize acceptance ceremony was a huge opportunity missed for all the Iranians who have suffered human rights abuses in the last 24 years of the Islamic dictatorship in Iran. The reason for this is non-other than what seems to be a genetic disease seen in a large number of older generation Iranians who forget the plight of their own people but prefer to take up the cause of others."
This is most distressing. In the past years and particularly in recent events I have witnessed many Iranians who by large are indifferent and not involved in political issues have suddenly shown concerns on US war against terrorism by taking actions against the American administration's policies or even have had the audacity of joining groups or demonstrations in support of Palestinians!
Was it Moshe Dayan who said of the Palestinians that they never waste an opportunity to waste an opportunity? It seems a Middle Eastern affliction sometimes. Posted by Orrin Judd at December 17, 2003 2:33 PM
I thought he said that about the Arabs generally.
Posted by: Matt C at December 18, 2003 1:44 AMAbba Eban said it.
Alas, it all depends on how you define "opportunity."
Eban assumed that his own definition of Palestinian "opportunity"---i.e., a Palestinian state existing side by side with Israel---was identical to the Palestinian definition of Palestinian "opportunity."
Wrong assumption. For Palestinians, "opportunity" has never meant co-existing with Israel.
One is forced to conclude that the Palestinians (et al.) have been pursuing their own brand of opportunity with zeal and will continue to do so. That opportunity hasn't yet been achieved (though there may be flickers of light at the end of that particular tunnel). Certainly, no opportunity has been "missed," unless one is referring to the Arab failures to eliminate Israel in 1948 and 1967.
Still, it's a great epigram, even if it makes absolutely no sense.
Posted by: Barry Meislin at December 18, 2003 3:26 AMMaybe, but she (Ebadi, not Hope) is a Muslim, so she hates us. Shrug.
Posted by: Harry Eagar at December 21, 2003 12:54 AM