September 11, 2003

TERTIATED:

The day Jimmy Carter was reduced to silence (Yehuda Avner, Sep. 11, 2003, Jerusalem Post)

"Mr. President," continued Begin in a tone that brooked no indifference, "This is our map of national security, and I use that term in its most unembellished sense. It is our map of survival. And the distinction between the past and the present is just that: survival. Today, our menfolk can defend their women and children. In the past they could not. Indeed, they had to deliver them to their Nazi executioners. We were tertiated, Mr. President."

Carter lifted his head. "What was that word, Mr. Prime Minister?"

"Tertiated, not decimated. The origin of the word 'decimation' is one in 10. When a Roman legion was found guilty of insubordination one in 10 was put to the sword. In our case it was one in three - tertiated!"

And now, with moistening eyes, and in a voice that was deliberate, stubborn, his every word weighed, Begin declared, "Sir, I take an oath before you in the name of the Jewish people - this will never ever happen again."

And then he broke down. He compressed his lips, which began to tremble.

Unseeingly, he stared at the map, struggling to blink back the tears. He clenched his fists and pressed them so tightly against the tabletop, his knuckles went white. He stood there, head bent, heart-broken, dignified.

A hush, as silent as a vault, settled on the room. Seized by his private, infernal Shoah reverie, he peered past Carter with a strange reserve in his eyes, a remote stare. It were as if he was looking through this born-again, Southern Baptist president from way inside himself, from that deep, Jewish intimate place of infinite lament and eternal faith - the place of long, long memory. And hidden down there, in that place, he was standing with Moses and the Maccabees.


So carve out a defensible state of Israel and give the rest to Arafat.

Posted by Orrin Judd at September 11, 2003 10:15 PM
Comments

Kill Arafat. Let God sort it out.

Posted by: Robert Schwartz at September 12, 2003 1:42 AM

"So carve out a defensible state of Israel and give the rest to Arafat."

Sorry, Orrin, with all due respect - Arafat deserves NOTHING except to be made an example of. Ordinary Palestinians should have their own state, to be sure, but they're saddled with one of the worst and most pusillanimous "leaderships" in my memory. After the events of the past three years, it should be obvious that no movement toward peace is possible until those so-called leaders are disposed of.

Posted by: Joe at September 12, 2003 5:23 AM

I forgot to add the most important thing: and Hamas. Hamas and its ilk must be utterly extirpated. They and their murderous actions, not anything Israel has done, are even more of an obstacle to peace than Arafat and his dithering cronies.

Posted by: Joe at September 12, 2003 5:24 AM

OJ and I occasionally come to the verge of disagreement.

But not here.

Posted by: Jeff Guinn at September 12, 2003 6:30 AM

I'm with Jeff and OJ, except to say that what Arafat needs is a bullet, not a state.

Posted by: Chris at September 12, 2003 10:25 AM

Chris:

Only if you can't find two.

Posted by: Jeff Guinn at September 12, 2003 12:01 PM

Jeff: Aim right, and you only need one. The brain stem is the trick.

Posted by: Chris at September 12, 2003 1:06 PM

I'm with Messrs. Judd and Guinn - the reality is we need to give Arafat a state before we can give him a bullet.

Posted by: Annoying Old Guy at September 12, 2003 5:05 PM

I think you can kill him and then give it to whoever. The Palestinians don't matter. This is about what's best for Israel, and us. That's statehood whether the Palestinians want it or not.

Posted by: oj at September 12, 2003 6:15 PM

I agree with the last. I saw the Chicago Tribune headline this morning--"Israel considers exile for Arafat." I blurted out, "Good, about time. But they need to put a bullet in his head instead."

What are the Pals gonna do about it? Shoot rockets at Israel? Bomb Jews? OH NO!!

Oh, wait--they are doing that now.

Posted by: ray at September 12, 2003 6:42 PM
« WHEN ELSE HAVE WE SEEN A DEMOCRAT BAR THE SCHOOLHOUSE DOOR?: | Main | IN VAIN?: »