March 19, 2003
THERE IS NO "I" IN "AMERICA":
The Perpendicular Pronoun (MAUREEN DOWD, 3/19/03, NY Times)Sometimes I feel as if I've spent half my adult life covering a President Bush as he squares off against Saddam Hussein, an evil dictator who invades his neighbors and gasses his own people.But while on the surface this seems like Groundhog War, the father-and-son duels in the sun with Saddam are breathtakingly different. The philosophical gulf between 41's gulf war and 43's gulf war is profound and cataclysmic--it has sent the whole world into a frenzy--yet it can be summed up in a single pronoun.
"The big I," as Bush senior calls it.
The first President Bush was often teased about his loopy syntax. But it was a way of speaking that signified the modesty and self-effacement his mother had insisted upon. He was so afraid to sound arrogant if he used the first person singular that he often just dropped the subject of a sentence and went straight to the verb.
"Mother always lectured us--in a kinder, gentler way--against using the big I," Poppy Bush said. He is so shy of "I" that he has never written a personal memoir.
For once, and only in this brief section of her column, Ms Dowd is absolutely correct. Bill Clinton always used to do the same thing, announcing actions of the United States by saying "I", and it drove me crazy. Nothing else Mr. Bush does or has done--with the exception of signing Campaign Finance Reform into law--disturbs more than the continual use of "I". It is unbecoming and in some sense disrespectful to the rest of the folks in his government, if not to the American people as a whole. He oughtta stop. Posted by Orrin Judd at March 19, 2003 7:59 AM
It is often true that the use of the word "I" reflects egotism, and an unwillingness to extend due credit to others.
However, sometimes I think it can show immodesty - the effort to inflate one's self beyond moral accountability, and the unwillingness to stand, humbly and alone, with one's convictions. The "royal we" is neither humble nor honest.
I have not noticed Bush's use of these pronouns. I'll watch from now on.
I haven't noticed W Bush's use of the pronoun either. I think sometimes the use of the word "I" instead of "we" can be an effort to shoulder the blame, should there be any.
In any case, I have noticed that he gets slammed when he uses the word "we."
Guess he's damned if he does and damned if he doesn't.
