March 6, 2003
LET HIS PEOPLE GO:
The peace message: 12 Reasons to Oppose a War with Iraq. (Russell Mokhiber and Robert Weissman, SF Bay Guardian)[P]articularly with the airwaves and op-ed pages dominated by warmongers who mock and mischaracterize the burgeoning peace movement, there remains a need to continually reiterate the common-sense reasons to oppose a war. Here are a dozen:1. Iraq is no threat to the United States [...]
2. Iraq is deterrable [...]
3. Iraq's only conceivable threat to the United States is in event of war [...]
4. Other terrorist risks rise in event of war [...]
5. U.S. soldiers are vulnerable to chemical or biological attack in a war [...]
6. Inspections can work [...]
7. Common sense says err on the side of nonviolence [...]
8. The doctrine of preventive war is a threat to international law and humanity [...]
9. Reject empire [...]
10. Revenge is not a legitimate motive for war [...]
11. There are better solutions to our energy problems [...]
12. Iraqi lives are at stake: Unless a war brings immediate abdication by Saddam, military action is sure to cause massive casualties among Iraqi conscripts and especially among Iraqi civilians. Solidarity with the Iraqi people – not their brutal government, but the people – requires opposition to a war almost certain to cause them enormous suffering.
Saddam Hussein himself said last year that 1.5 million Iraqis had died since the sanctions regime was imposed--how many more are we willing to let die before he's deposed? Posted by Orrin Judd at March 6, 2003 4:16 PM
All experience says #7 is backwards.
Posted by: Harry Eagar at March 6, 2003 6:51 PMNot only that, but several of these "reasons" contradict other "reasons" in the list. From that I assume this isn't supposed to be a comprehensive argument against, but a menu from which one is supposed to pick the ones that "feel" best. Or generates the best bumper sticker slogan.
Oh, and this is the best they can come up with?
Did any of these reasons apply for the Left when Clinton went to war with Serbia?
Posted by: Thomas J. Jackson at March 7, 2003 12:02 AMThomas --
Many, many people of the left were opposed to American military action in the Balkans. Reasons 7, 8 and 9 were the most commonly stated.
I bet they feel right idiots now, don't they, Peter?
Posted by: Harry Eagar at March 7, 2003 1:49 PMIs it me or does reasons #4 and #5 smack of cowardice? "If we go to war we might get hurt." "If we go to hurt others may become angry with us and try to hurt us."
Regards,
