February 6, 2003

THE MEANING OF KASHISH:

The Coldest War: High in the Karakoram, the stubborn armies of India and Pakistan have faced off for 19 years on the Siachen Glacier, the world's highest battleground and a flash point in the deadly dispute over Kashmir. In this exclusive report, an American writer and photographer spend two months inside the ultimate no-man's-land, witnessing the human and environmental devastation of a conflict without end. (Kevin Fedarko, February 2003, Outside Magazine)
Ghyari sits between soaring granite walls as bold and majestic as El Capitan, threaded with waterfalls that turn to mist before they hit the valley floor. Farther up this valley lie several Pakistani artillery batteries, which lob shells at the Indian posts dug in on the ridges above. Ghyari is a supply center and rehab station for worn-out soldiers—they recuperate after coming down from the front, or pause to acclimatize before marching up to relieve their comrades, who are rotated out every two to eight weeks to prevent high-altitude sickness and brain damage.

The Ghyari base consists of a dozen neatly whitewashed buildings and a 600-year-old mosque established by Sayyid Ali Hamadani, who introduced Islam to Baltistan in the 14th century. A few steps from the mosque sits an underground bunker that serves as a studio for a young man named Makhtar, who paints portraits of the shaheeds, or martyrs—soldiers who have been killed in this war and thereby gained admission to paradise. The Pakistanis believe their religious faith gives them motivation that the Indians lack. "The concepts of jihad and shahadat—or 'life after death'—help us strike hard," explained Major Sikendar Hayat, 41, second in command at Ghyari. "It is what we call a force-multiplier."

Islam isn't the only influence on this army; as is true on the Indian side, its rituals are clearly British. At the heart of the base sits a crude cricket field said to be the highest in the world. On our first afternoon at Ghyari, a Sunday, the officers gathered on a row of folding chairs to watch a match. In front of them was a low table with a field telephone that squawked every few minutes as posts called in reports.

After two hours of casual cricket talk—"Good batting, sir!"... "Shabash! Well done!"—the game was halted for high tea. The officers rearranged their chairs in a circle while the sirdar, a bearded man in a white lace skullcap, started serving them. Without warning, a massive, hollow boom resounded from the ridges up near the front lines.

"Artillery?" asked Major Sikendar, looking behind him.

"Rockslide," responded a second officer.

"Must be artillery," said a third.

"Phone!" barked the commanding officer, a chiseled lieutenant colonel on his third tour of Siachen duty.

Sikendar seized the green field telephone, cranked the handle, listened, grunted. Everyone else stared at the ground. After a minute or two, it emerged that dynamite was being used to clear a route blocked by a landslide. The tension ratcheted down a notch, but the tea was now cold. Sunday afternoon cricket was over.


It's hard not to despair over the kind of ethnic hatreds that leave two peoples fighting over a glacier. A long but fascinating piece (does Outside not have a print friendly function?).

MORE:
ARCHIVES (Mag Portal)

Posted by Orrin Judd at February 6, 2003 8:09 AM
Comments

Why not? Where there are no glaciers

available, they fight over imaginary

deities.

Posted by: Harry at February 6, 2003 11:58 PM

Yes, but we seldom see Darwinists and Baptists actually go to fist city.

Posted by: oj at February 7, 2003 12:28 AM

It's not really just about religion.



For Pakistan it's partly about getting control of the sources of the rivers which flow through the country, which is pretty crucial since the bulk of the economy is still based on agriculture.



Propoganda-wise it's dressed up as a valiant struggle to free fellow Muslims from Hindu repression although one would suspect Kashmiri Muslims are sick of the fighting by now and there are very few who would want to have Kashmir become part of Pakistan anyway.



Frankly I think the struggle is kept up by the Pakistan Army to ensure the bulk of the country's earnings flow to them and for the brass to maintain their position in high society and benefit from illegal deals.



If it ever ended then people might begin to ask hard questions about why money currently being spent on defence couldn't be directed to education, health and infrastructure spending.

Posted by: M Ali Choudhury at February 7, 2003 4:22 AM

Ali:



That's a day to be prayed for.

Posted by: oj at February 7, 2003 5:47 PM
« WHAT, NO ROLLERSKATING TRAINS?: | Main | STRUMMIN' HER PAIN WITH HIS FINGERS (via the esteemed Kevin Whited): »