December 5, 2007

THERE'S NO GRANT MONEY IN BUCKING MALTHUS:

The Science of Gore's Nobel: What if everyone believes in global warmism only because everyone believes in global warmism? (HOLMAN W. JENKINS JR., December 5, 2007, Opinion Journal)

How this honor has befallen the former Veep could perhaps be explained by another Nobel, awarded in 2002 to Daniel Kahneman for work he and the late Amos Tversky did on "availability bias," roughly the human propensity to judge the validity of a proposition by how easily it comes to mind.

Their insight has been fruitful and multiplied: "Availability cascade" has been coined for the way a proposition can become irresistible simply by the media repeating it; "informational cascade" for the tendency to replace our beliefs with the crowd's beliefs; and "reputational cascade" for the rational incentive to do so.

Mr. Gore clearly understands the game he's playing, judging by his resort to such nondispositive arguments as: "The people who dispute the international consensus on global warming are in the same category now with the people who think the moon landing was staged in a movie lot in Arizona."

Here's exactly the problem that availability cascades pose: What if the heads being counted to certify an alleged "consensus" arrived at their positions by counting heads?

It may seem strange that scientists would participate in such a phenomenon. It shouldn't. Scientists are human; they do not wait for proof; many devote their professional lives to seeking evidence for hypotheses (especially well-funded hypotheses) they've chosen to believe.

Posted by Orrin Judd at December 5, 2007 11:04 AM
Comments

What a putz. The moon landing was staged in Nevada, not Arizona!

Everyone knows that. And we're supposed to trust Al on anything else?

Doofus.

Posted by: Andrew X at December 5, 2007 11:33 AM
« YOU DON'T GET THAT BAD WITHOUT REALLY TRYING: | Main | DO YOU WANT TO PAY FOR FOOD OR BAGGERS?: »