October 20, 2020

MAKING THEM PRO-SCIENCE!

Trump and the right share a social Darwinist "herd mentality" -- it leads to widespread death (CARL POPE, OCTOBER 20, 2020, Salon)

Herd immunity can sometimes reduce mortality from a disease, but over the centuries has failed to end the curse of influenza, tuberculosis, smallpox, polio, rabies or dengue fever. It fits neatly, however, into a social Darwinist framework. Those who die are the "weak" -- the poorest, the youngest and the oldest young -- or can at any rate be classified as weak and deserving to die, because they died. Survival of the fittest requires discarding the weak. Remember the "let them die" hecklers who populated some of the 2011 Republican debates on health care. 

This underlying value distortion -- my personal freedom extends to my right to endanger you -- spreads out across a range of other issues. Today's Republican reluctance to curb pollution even when it is demonstrably is killing a power plant's neighbors, to keep pesticides that kill farm workers out of the fields or to do anything at all about the climate crisis, which conservatives have privately conceded for years was real and caused by carbon pollution, are all illustrations of how the toxin of social Darwinism still contaminates much of the right's thinking about freedom.

So Trump's response to the COVID crisis -- and the willingness of the Republican congressional establishment to enable it -- illustrates a deep-rooted flaw in the American right. In a world in which we are, like it or not, all bound together, a tolerable conservatism is one that is willing to protect me from irresponsible neighbors, whether those are COVID-risking teenagers, irresponsible gun owners or multinational chemical companies.

The Right is the Left.

Posted by at October 20, 2020 12:00 AM

  

« OUR BETTER HALVES: | Main | WELL, THAT'S THAT: »