September 21, 2020

THOMAS SOWELL WROTE ABOUT THIS DECADES AGO:

WHO'S LEFT OUT OF THE NEW AMERICAN MAINSTREAM? (RICHARD ALBA | SEPTEMBER 21, 2020, Zocalo Public Square)

At a moment when the eyes of the nation are fixed on Black Lives Matter and the anti-racism struggle, it may seem odd to call attention to quiet breaches of America's ethno-racial dividing lines. A South Asian immigrant family moving into a predominantly white suburb; an African American promoted to a position with authority over white employees; or the celebration of a marriage between white and Mexican-American partners--events like these, which are now common in many parts of the U.S., don't appear to augur much social change. But their cumulative impact can be transformative.

Consider in this light the upper reaches of the workforce. During the 20th century, white Americans monopolized the highest-paying jobs. In 2000, nearly 85 percent of the baby-boom workers occupying the top quarter of occupations (ranked by annual salary) were white.

But, since the beginning of the new century--and as a consequence in part of the demographic decline in the numbers of young whites entering the labor market--the young adults starting these jobs have increasingly been non-white or Hispanic. (These figures are derived from the Census, so I use the Census term "Hispanic" in that context.) Now, one-third of the new job entrants are minorities. That means not just more persons of color with good incomes, but fewer whites in positions of authority--to decide who gets hired or promoted.

But there's a catch. The minority individuals benefitting from upper-level opportunity are predominantly from recent immigrant backgrounds--they are mainly Asian Americans, both immigrant and native-born, and U.S.-born Latinos. But the share of Black Americans in these good jobs has budged just slightly over time and hovers around 5 percent.

A similar disparity appears in the surging diversity at colleges and universities, which is likewise dominated by immigrant-origin minorities. The 2019 report of the American Council on Education highlights a steep rise in the number of Latino graduates--including a doubling of the annual number earning baccalaureates in 2004-14 alone. Correspondingly, the share of whites among graduates dropped from 73 to 64 percent in the same period. At elite universities, the white share of students has fallen sharply over several decades.

But for Black Americans, the decades of the new century have not brought such good news. Their college graduation rates grew strongly during the second half of the 20th century but have slumped recently. That same ACE report notes that Black students have relatively high rates of dropout from baccalaureate programs, and have the highest level of student indebtedness. At a time of rapidly growing diversity among college students, the stagnating fortunes of Black students are an unacknowledged crisis.

Properly considered, reparations are just a way to compensate American blacks for our depriving them of the normal immigrant experience, which is a springboard to the middle classes.

Posted by at September 21, 2020 12:00 AM

  

« THE GREEN NEW DEAL IS TOO CONSERVATIVE: | Main | DOFFING THE HOOD: »