September 2, 2019

IDENTITIES ARE CREATED, NOT BORN INTO (profanity alert):

Lionel Shriver returns to Australia and doubles down on 'fascistic' identity politics (Debbie Zhou, 1 Sep 2019, The Guardian)

Three years after vowing never to return to Australia, author Lionel Shriver says she stands by her controversial keynote speech at the Brisbane writers' festival in 2016, calling identity politics "fascistic".

Sunday night marked the American novelist's first appearance in Australia since that controversial tour, despite her having released two books in the intervening years.

Shriver's 2016 address on fiction and identity politics, in which she said she hoped "the concept of 'cultural appropriation' is a passing fad", received widespread backlash. Sudanese-Australian writer Yassmin Abdel-Magied walked out of the event midway, later writing in the Guardian that Shriver's argument - that fiction writers shouldn't need to seek permission to write on minority cultures - "became a celebration of the unfettered exploitation of the experiences of others, under the guise of fiction".

But on Sunday night, Shriver, speaking to an intimate crowd of 150 at Sydney's Bookoccino event, said her only regret in the controversy was the way it was reported. Abdel-Magied's opinion piece sparked an international uproar and debate, with stories in the New York Times and the New Yorker. The Orange prize-winning novelist on Sunday reiterated her arguments from the keynote, warning of the dangers of "a larger cultural cowardice".

"So ultimately [for] this movement - I'm sorry to throw around what sounds like hyperbole - but the end point is fascistic. Because it's about control. It's about silence. It's about obedience. It's about conformism. It's about imposing a way of thinking," she said. [...]

She resisted the idea that people should be defined as part of the "groups we're a member of, and what order we are in the social hierarchy", saying she doesn't believe "race, gender or sexual proclivity" are forms of identity. This line of thought led her to penning a controversial essay in the Spectator in 2018, in which she expressed her disagreement with Penguin Random House's diversity quotas.

"To tell me that identity comes down to these little boxes that we were born into ... [is] depressing and also politically regressive," she said. "I find that a really grim, ugly, flat way of looking at the world."

Posted by at September 2, 2019 12:00 AM

  

« THE CULTURE OF DEATH: | Main | FROM WHO? TO WHAT?: »