February 5, 2018
INFORMATION WANTS TO BE FREE:
The Times Asks Court to Unseal Documents on Surveillance of Carter Page (CHARLIE SAVAGE and ADAM GOLDMAN, FEB. 5, 2018, NY Times)
The New York Times is asking the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court to unseal secret documents related to the wiretapping of Carter Page, the onetime Trump campaign adviser at the center of a disputed memo written by Republican staffers on the House Intelligence Committee.The motion is unusual. No such wiretapping application materials apparently have become public since Congress first enacted the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act in 1978. That law regulates electronic spying on domestic soil -- the interception of phone calls and emails -- undertaken in the name of monitoring suspected spies and terrorists, as opposed to wiretapping for investigating ordinary criminal suspects.Normally, even the existence of such material is a closely guarded secret. While applications for criminal wiretaps often eventually become public, the government has refused to disclose the contents of applications for intelligence wiretaps -- even to defendants who are later prosecuted on the basis of information derived from them.But President Trump lowered the shield of secrecy surrounding such materials on Friday by declassifying the Republican memo about Mr. Page, after finding that the public interest in disclosing its contents outweighed any need to protect the information. Because Mr. Trump did so, the Times argues, there is no longer a justification "for the Page warrant orders and application materials to be withheld in their entirety," and "disclosure would serve the public interest."
Secrets almost never serve the public interest. It's not the breaking of the Enigma device they're hiding.
Posted by Orrin Judd at February 5, 2018 3:57 PM
