September 28, 2016
WHAHAPPEN?:
The Darwinism of Hollywood Filmmakers (ROBERT BRENNAN, 9/27/16, Crisis)
Kubrick did not obsess on mankind's penchant for violence as Peckinpah, but his overriding theme in most of his work seemed fascinated by man as an absurdity, especially when he is thinking he is something special. He directed across a wide spectrum and diverse sampling of American cinema pallets--the crime/caper film The Killing--two great anti-war films Paths of Glory and Dr. Strangelove--a one of a kind epic Spartacus. Even though I only understand thirty percent of it, a high-end science fiction film was unheard of until Kubrick willed it into existence in the form of 2001 A Space Odyssey. It is within the opening sequence of this Kubrick master work where Robert Ardrey's beliefs in the nature of man bloom in 70mm wide screen splendor.No need for a spoiler alert here as the opening scene of the ape-man creature figuring out what to do with the animal bone at the water hole has become so culturally ubiquitous. No doubt it is a great piece of filmmaking as the ape-man slowly figures out what he's got in his hands and then sets about becoming Ardrey's "killer ape" in a slow motion ballet of violence as he lets all the other ape-men know which side of the watering hole belongs to whom.Like Peckinpah, Kubrick was introduced to the works of Robert Ardrey by their mutual acting acquaintance. Ardrey's hypothesis shows up time and again in other Kubrick movies. Man is just the sum of his DNA. Violence and injustice and nihilism are his only true inheritances. His Roman epic Spartacus is praised in many critical corners precisely because it is one of the few ancient Roman epics made by a major studio that does not have a Christian subtext of any kind.
Except, of course, that 2001 is the most Designist film ever made, positing the opposite of what is proposed here. The apes do not learn to use tools and commit violence until the obelisk, obviously a product of intelligence, shows up and changes them. Indeed, the film pretty much demonstrates that no one believes in Darwinism when push comes to shove.
Posted by Orrin Judd at September 28, 2016 1:28 PM
