March 21, 2016


Actually, Most Evangelicals Don't Vote Trump : The numbers tell a different story than the headlines. (Darren Patrick Guerra, MARCH 18, 2016, Christianity Today)

[E]ven in Florida, Trump only garnered 19 percent of votes from those who chose their candidate based on "shared values." This includes both Catholics and evangelicals. This hardly supports a conclusion that "values voters" are in Trump's back pocket. In contrast, Cruz carried pluralities of evangelicals in Missouri (46 percent), North Carolina (43 percent), and Illinois (37 percent) while Kasich carried a plurality of evangelicals in Ohio (43 percent). It seems misleading to continually push a narrative that evangelicals are en masse supporting Trump when his win-loss record (in terms of pluralities) was a paltry 1-5. A win-loss record like that wouldn't even earn him a spot on the Miami Marlins starting pitching rotation.

One plausible alternative narrative coming out of the March 15 primaries is that evangelicals actually slowed Trump's advance in Missouri and Illinois and helped defeat him in Ohio. This conclusion is based on the fact that Trump performed worse among evangelicals than non-evangelicals in all three of those states. In addition, Kasich and Cruz each beat Trump among evangelicals by the same margin of eight points in both Ohio and Missouri, respectively.

Across all the states, the March 15 elections showed that, on average, a super-majority of 60 percent of evangelicals voted for someone other than Trump. Furthermore, there continues to be strong evidence that the more religious a voter is, the less likely they are to support Donald Trump. For example, in Missouri exit polls, which tracked church attendance, Trump performed much worse than Ted Cruz. Of those who attend religious services "more than once a week," Cruz garnered 56 percent of the vote, outpacing Trump by a full 26 percentage points. Among those who attend religious services once a week, Cruz earned 50 percent of the vote, which was a full 17 points above Trump.

In contrast, with those who only attend services "a few" times a year, Trump won 48 percent of the vote to Cruz's 29 percent. If Missouri's numbers are indicative of voters in other states, then Trump does much worse among those who actually take their faith seriously enough to attend religious services consistently. There is some recent research by The Barna Group reported on by Vox, which suggests these numbers are indeed consistent with a broader pattern among evangelical voters nationally.

Posted by at March 21, 2016 5:57 PM