March 20, 2015
BLUE LIGHT SPECIAL:
The Case for Free-Range Parenting (Clemens Wergin, 3/20/15, NY Times)
ON her first morning in America, last summer, my daughter went out to explore her new neighborhood -- alone, without even telling my wife or me.Of course we were worried; we had just moved from Berlin, and she was just 8. But when she came home, we realized we had no reason to panic. Beaming with pride, she told us and her older sister how she had discovered the little park around the corner, and had made friends with a few local dog owners. She had taken possession of her new environment, and was keen to teach us things we didn't know.When this story comes up in conversations with American friends, we are usually met with polite disbelief. Most are horrified by the idea that their children might roam around without adult supervision. In Berlin, where we lived in the center of town, our girls would ride the Metro on their own -- a no-no in Washington. Or they'd go alone to the playground, or walk a mile to a piano lesson. Here in quiet and traffic-safe suburban Washington, they don't even find other kids on the street to play with. On Halloween, when everybody was out to trick or treat, we were surprised by how many children actually lived here whom we had never seen.A study by the University of California, Los Angeles, has found that American kids spend 90 percent of their leisure time at home, often in front of the TV or playing video games. Even when kids are physically active, they are watched closely by adults, either in school, at home, at afternoon activities or in the car, shuttling them from place to place.Such narrowing of the child's world has happened across the developed world. But Germany is generally much more accepting of letting children take some risks. To this German parent, it seems that America's middle class has taken overprotective parenting to a new level, with the government acting as a super nanny.
When we had one kid, he wouldn't follow me from the toy section at K-Mart, so I just left him behind. Eventually there was a PA announcement asking for Griffin's dad to come claim his child. Fellow shoppers looked on in disbelief. But from then on he came when I told him to. So I did the same thing with his sister a few years later and it worked out the same.
Of course, I stayed home with the third and he's nearly feral. After about an hour I had to go fish him out of the toy section where he was still playing blissfully.
Posted by Orrin Judd at March 20, 2015 7:33 PM
Tweet
