January 10, 2015

WHICH IS WHY THE UR WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER OFF PASSING NATIONAL HEALTH:

The Left's Unpopular Populism : Elizabeth Warren and her Democratic allies should not fool themselves into thinking that Americans who are angry at elites and corporations also favor wealth redistribution. (AMITAI ETZIONI, JAN 8 2015, The Atlantic)

Populism usually refers to the idea that power should rest in the hands of the little guy, and not in the government or some elite. Public-opinion polls show that this basic form of populism has wide appeal. One of every two Americans believes that most politicians are corrupt (51 percent, according to a 2013 poll of national voters); 76 percent that special interests wield too much power; and 88 percent that big money has too much sway. Very low on people's "trust" lists are all those perceived as powerful, including not just the government but also banks and corporations and labor unions. This kind of populism appeals to both those on the left, such as the Occupy Wall Street folks, and to Tea Partiers. (Polls show that, at least for a while, at least one in 10 Americans favored both!) I call this popular populism.

Much of the appeal is lost--that is, populism becomes much less popular--once leftist themes join the mix. There is little support for policies that look like wealth transfers, taking from the rich and giving to poor, reducing inequality, or making sacrifices for the common good. Large segments of the right and center view these policies as taking from "us" and giving to "them." That's why Social Security is so popular, while welfare is not. It's the reason Medicare is very popular and Medicaid is much less so.  

Opinions about what the top problems facing the nation are differ somewhat from poll to poll and over time. However, in one poll after another, popular populism concerns rank much higher than leftist ones. Thus a January 2014 poll found that dissatisfaction with the government, politicians, and poor leadership ranked as the main concerns, with the economy in general as the second. Only 4 percent of respondents ranked poverty, hunger, and homelessness as top concerns, just one percentage point higher than the very unpopular foreign aid. Even among Democrats, dissatisfaction with government ranked three times higher than the rich-poor gap (6 percent).

This is one reason why Obamacare remains unpopular.

Republican reform of Obamacare will save it by making make it universal.

Posted by at January 10, 2015 8:41 AM
  

blog comments powered by Disqus
« THE DRAGON HAS NO TEETH: | Main | THE WAR ON SCIENCE: »